BBQration 28-Inch Replacement Griddle Top Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are looking for bbqration upgrade 28 griddle top alternatives because your current surface needs replacement or you want different cooking characteristics. The BBQration top offers a heavy-duty 34.7-pound steel plate with an X-shape design to reduce warping. It provides a wide 28 by 17 inch cooking area and fits multiple Blackstone models. However, you might prefer a different material like stainless steel for corrosion resistance. You may also want a complete unit rather than just a replacement top, or a smaller footprint for portable use.
We selected these 6 options because their specifications overlap with your needs. Some choices offer full griddle systems with hoods and burners. Others provide stainless steel surfaces or smaller tabletop units. One option is a silicone mat for protection rather than a new cooking surface. Each pick addresses specific gaps in the original product, such as weight, material, or included accessories. Review the specs to find the best match for your cooking style and available space.
Our top pick: BBQration 28-Inch Replacement Griddle Top.
How Each Alternative Compares
Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
The Stanbroil stainless steel top shifts material from carbon steel to corrosion-resistant stainless steel. This choice eliminates the need for the seasoning process required by the BBQration plate, offering a low-maintenance surface for Camp Chef FTG600 and FTG900PG owners. It includes a removable grease trough for easier cleanup compared to the BBQration’s integrated windshield design. However, it lacks the specific X-shape warping reduction found in the BBQration unit. You should choose this if you prioritize rust resistance and simple maintenance over the heavy-duty heat retention of the original.
Cuisinart 17-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle
The Cuisinart CGG-9291 is a complete tabletop gas griddle rather than a replacement top. It weighs only 18.4 pounds, significantly lighter than the 34.7-pound BBQration plate, making it ideal for portable outdoor events. It features a 17-inch cooking surface, which is narrower than the 28-inch BBQration option. This unit is self-contained with its own gas burner, whereas the BBQration top requires an existing griddle frame. Pick this model if you need a standalone, lightweight unit for small groups instead of a heavy replacement part for a large stationary grill.
Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle
The Blackstone 1517 Omnivore is a full-size stationary griddle, not a replacement top. It weighs 69 pounds, nearly double the weight of the BBQration plate, and requires a dedicated stand or cart. It offers a massive 28-inch cooking width with integrated side shelves and storage, providing far more workspace than a simple top replacement. This unit is designed for permanent outdoor kitchen setups. You should select this if you want a complete cooking system with high capacity and heat efficiency, rather than just a durable surface to swap into an existing frame.
Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood
The Blackstone 1813 is a compact 22-inch tabletop griddle, smaller than the 28-inch BBQration replacement. It weighs 37.5 pounds and includes its own hood, providing two distinct heat zones for versatile cooking. Unlike the BBQration top, which is a bare plate, this unit is a complete appliance with its own gas system. It is designed for small groups and portable use where a full-size unit is too large. Choose this if you need a smaller, self-contained griddle with a protective hood, rather than a large replacement surface for a bigger existing grill.
Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat
The Protebox silicone mat is a protective cover, not a cooking surface. It weighs just 1.43 pounds and is designed to fit 22-inch griddles, making it incompatible with the 28-inch BBQration top. Its primary function is rust prevention and easy storage, offering zero heat retention or cooking capability. It is a passive accessory that sits on the griddle when not in use. You should pick this if you already own a compatible 22-inch unit and need a lightweight cover for maintenance, rather than a heavy-duty steel plate for active cooking.
Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle for Weber Q
The Uniflasy cast iron griddle is a small accessory for Weber Q series grills, not a replacement for a Blackstone. It measures 12.6 by 8.6 inches, providing a much smaller cooking area than the 28-inch BBQration plate. Made of cast iron, it offers excellent heat retention but lacks the wide surface needed for large meals. It is designed for side dishes or breakfast foods on portable gas grills. Select this if you own a Weber Q and need a small flat top accessory, rather than a large replacement top for a dedicated outdoor griddle station.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
BBQration 28-Inch Replacement Griddle Top
Best for: Replacing tops on standard 28-inch Blackstone griddles
- Form Factor
- Griddle Top
- Dimensions
- 20 × 3 × 8 inches
- Weight
- 34.7 pounds
View on Amazon: BBQration 28-Inch Replacement Griddle Top Affiliate link
This is a 28-inch replacement griddle top for Blackstone 1517 and similar models. It measures 28 by 17 by 2.5 inches and weighs 34.7 pounds. The X-shaped back design helps reduce warping and improves heat recovery. You need to season the bare metal surface before first use. It fits original tabletop griddles but not the 28-inch 3-Burner XL version.
Pros
- 28-inch cooking surface fits Blackstone 1517, 1853, 1605, and other 28-inch models
- X-shaped back design reduces warping and improves heat recovery
- Built-in windshield helps maintain high temperatures and reduces fuel use
- Weighs 34.7 pounds for a sturdy build
Cons
- Requires manual seasoning before first use as it has no chemical coating
- May not fit exactly into the original hood due to design differences
- Not compatible with the Blackstone 28-inch 3-Burner XL Griddle
Good fit if
- You own a Blackstone 28-inch griddle (models 1517, 1853, 1605, etc.)
- You want a replacement top with better warping resistance
- You are comfortable seasoning raw metal surfaces
Skip if
- You have a Blackstone 28-inch 3-Burner XL Griddle
- You prefer a pre-seasoned surface with no maintenance
- You need a guaranteed perfect fit with the original hood
Verdict: BBQration 28" Replacement Griddle Top is a heavy-duty replacement for owners of standard 28-inch Blackstone griddles who need a durable surface with improved heat recovery. It suits those willing to season the metal and verify their hood fitment.
Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
Best for: Camp Chef FTG600 and FTG900PG owners
- Cooking Area
- 476 square in.
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel
- Cooking Dimensions
- 28 x 17 inches
- Application
- Camping
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
View on Amazon: Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top Affiliate link
This replacement griddle top is designed for Camp Chef FTG600, FTG900PG, and FTG600P models. It features a 28 by 17 inch cooking surface that provides 476 square inches of space. The heavy-duty stainless steel construction offers corrosion resistance and handles drastic temperature changes without cracking. A removable grease trough and high sides help manage flare-ups and wind. It includes convenient side handles for easy movement.
Pros
- 28 by 17 inch stainless steel cooking surface
- 476 square inches of total cooking area
- Removable grease trough for easier cleaning
- High-side design blocks wind and dust
- Chemical-free flat top for safe cooking
Cons
- Limited to specific Camp Chef grill models
- No included hood or warming rack
- Stainless steel surface requires seasoning or oiling
Good fit if
- You own a Camp Chef FTG600, FTG900PG, or FTG600P grill
- You need a durable replacement for a worn original top
- You prefer a corrosion-resistant stainless steel cooking surface
Skip if
- You cook on a Blackstone or Weber grill
- You need a tabletop griddle for small spaces
- You want a complete griddle system with a hood
Verdict: Stanbroil Stainless Steel Griddle for Camp Chef fits Camp Chef FTG600, FTG900PG, and FTG600P owners who need a durable, wide replacement top. It offers a large, corrosion-resistant cooking area with practical features like a removable grease trough.
Cuisinart 17-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle
Best for: small groups and portable outdoor events
- Cooking Area
- 255 sq. in.
- Fuel Type
- Gas
- Total Heat Output
- 12,000 BTU
- Surface Material
- Carbon Steel
- Form Factor
- Tabletop
- Placement
- Outdoor
View on Amazon: Cuisinart 17-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle Affiliate link
This tabletop griddle offers 255 square inches of carbon steel cooking space. It delivers 12,000 BTUs from a single stainless steel burner. The unit weighs 18.4 pounds and measures 23.8 inches wide. You can assemble the legs and grease cup brackets in 15 minutes. Its compact size suits camping, tailgating, and picnics. It fits six steaks or twelve burgers at once.
Pros
- 255 square inch carbon steel surface
- 12,000 BTU single stainless steel burner
- Assembles in 15 minutes
- Compact tabletop design
Cons
- Single burner limits heat zoning
- 255 sq. in. is smaller than 28-inch models
- 18.4 pounds weight adds bulk for travel
Good fit if
- You need a compact unit for camping or tailgating
- You want quick assembly without complex tools
- You cook for small groups of four to six people
Skip if
- You require a large surface for feeding more than six people
- You prefer a full-size griddle for family gatherings
- You need multiple burners for separate cooking zones
Verdict: Cuisinart 17-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle fits you if you prioritize portability and quick setup for small outdoor gatherings. It is not suitable for large family cookouts requiring extensive cooking space.
Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle
Best for: large-capacity stationary outdoor cooking
- Cooking Area
- 517 sq. in.
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Burners
- 2
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 22.8 × 44 × 33 inches
- Weight
- 69 pounds
View on Amazon: Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle Affiliate link
This Blackstone 1517 offers 517 square inches of cooking space with a 28-inch width. It features a specialized Omnivore griddle plate designed for faster preheat times, better heat distribution, and improved fuel efficiency. The unit includes built-in wind guards, side shelves, and a rear grease management system. Weighing 69 pounds, it moves easily on caster wheels. This model suits you if you want a large, efficient outdoor cooking surface with dedicated prep areas.
Pros
- 517 square inches of cooking area
- Omnivore plate for faster heat recovery
- Built-in wind guards for stability
- Rear grease management system
- Caster wheels for easy movement
Cons
- Heavy at 69 pounds
- Takes up significant space at 44 inches wide
- Only includes a one-year limited warranty
Good fit if
- You need a large cooking surface for family meals
- You want efficient heat distribution and fuel use
- You prefer a unit with side shelves for prep
Skip if
- You have limited storage space for a 44-inch unit
- You need a portable griddle under 50 pounds
- You require a warranty longer than one year
Verdict: Blackstone 1517 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle fits you if you prioritize cooking capacity and heat efficiency over portability. It is ideal for stationary outdoor kitchens where you can manage its weight and size.
Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood
Best for: compact outdoor cooking with two zones
- Cooking Area
- 361 sq. in.
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Burners
- 2
- Form Factor
- Tabletop
- Cover Type
- Integrated Hood
- Material
- Stainless Steel
View on Amazon: Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood Affiliate link
This Blackstone 1813 is a 22-inch tabletop griddle with 361 square inches of cooking space. It features two independently heated zones for versatile cooking. The unit includes an integrated hood for protection and a rear grease management system. Weighing 37.5 pounds, it is portable enough for picnics or tailgating. It suits those needing a compact, dedicated griddle surface.
Pros
- 22-inch cooking surface with 361 square inches of space
- Two independently heated zones for different temperatures
- Integrated hood protects the griddle top
- Rear grease management system for easy cleanup
- Piezo ignition for quick starting
Cons
- Smaller 22-inch size compared to 28-inch alternatives
- Heavier at 37.5 pounds than portable mats
- Tabletop form factor requires a stable surface
Good fit if
- You need a dedicated griddle for smaller gatherings
- You want two separate cooking zones
- You prefer a unit with a protective hood
Skip if
- You require a full-size 28-inch cooking area
- You need a lightweight, foldable mat
- You plan to cook for large crowds regularly
Verdict: Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle fits users who want a compact, standalone griddle with two heat zones and a protective hood. It is ideal for small groups or portable use where a full-size unit is too large.
Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat
Best for: protecting 22-inch griddle surfaces
- Included Accessories
- Cover
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 22.3 × 16.8 × 0.98 inches
- Weight
- 1.43 pounds
View on Amazon: Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat Affiliate link
This is a protective cover for the Blackstone 22-inch griddle. It measures 22.3 by 16.8 inches with a 0.98-inch height. The heavy-duty food-grade silicone material resists rust, dust, and moisture. It folds for easy storage and cleans quickly. You should use this if you need to shield your cooking surface from weather damage between uses.
Pros
- Made from 100% food-grade silicone
- High-sided design collects debris
- Fits Blackstone 22-inch griddles
- Non-stick and waterproof surface
Cons
- Only protects the surface, does not cook
- Smaller coverage than 28-inch options
- Requires manual cleaning after use
Good fit if
- You own a 22-inch Blackstone griddle
- You need rust prevention for storage
- You want a foldable protective cover
Skip if
- You have a 28-inch or larger griddle
- You need a cooking surface, not a cover
- You prefer a rigid metal guard
Verdict: Protebox 22" Silicone Griddle Mat offers targeted protection for smaller 22-inch units. It is the right pick if you prioritize rust prevention and easy storage over full-size coverage.
Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle for Weber Q
Best for: Weber Q series grill owners needing a small flat top
- Surface Material
- Cast Iron
- Fuel Type
- Gas
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 12.6 × 8.6 × 0.5 inches
View on Amazon: Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle for Weber Q Affiliate link
This Uniflasy cast iron plate replaces the cooking surface on Weber Q1200, Q1000, Q120, and Q100 gas grills. Measuring 12.6 by 8.6 inches, it covers half the grill area. The 0.5-inch thick matte cast iron retains heat well and prevents sticking. It includes support clips for secure installation. You can use the remaining grill space for traditional grilling while using the flat surface for smaller items like bacon or shrimp.
Pros
- Made of heavy-duty matte cast iron for even heat distribution
- Specifically designed to fit Weber Q1200, Q1000, Q120, and Q100 series grills
- Includes griddle support clips for secure and easy installation
- Raised lip around the edge prevents food from falling off during cooking
Cons
- Small 12.6 by 8.6 inch surface area limits cooking capacity
- Covers only half the grill, requiring you to manage two cooking zones
- Requires manual seasoning and careful cleaning to prevent rust
Good fit if
- You own a Weber Q1200, Q1000, Q120, or Q100 gas grill
- You want to add a flat surface for breakfast items or vegetables
- You prefer the heat retention and flavor of cast iron
Skip if
- You need a full-size griddle that covers the entire grill width
- You are looking for a non-stick stainless steel or porcelain surface
- You want a griddle that fits Blackstone or other brand grills
Verdict: Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle for Weber Q1200 is a targeted accessory for Weber Q series owners. It fits those who need a small, durable flat top for side dishes or breakfast foods on their portable gas grill. It does not replace the main grill for large meals.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | BBQration 28-Inch Replacement Griddle Top | Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top | Cuisinart 17-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle | Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle | Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood | Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat | Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle for Weber Q |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking Area | not stated | 476 square in. | 255 sq. in. | 517 sq. in. | 361 sq. in. | not stated | not stated |
| Fuel Type | not stated | not stated | Gas | Propane | Propane | not stated | not stated |
| Burners | not stated | not stated | not stated | 2 | 2 | not stated | not stated |
| Total Heat Output | not stated | not stated | 12,000 BTU | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Surface Material | not stated | Stainless Steel | Carbon Steel | not stated | not stated | not stated | Cast Iron |
| Form Factor | Griddle Top | not stated | Tabletop | not stated | Tabletop | not stated | not stated |
| Cooking Dimensions | not stated | 28 x 17 inches | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Cover Type | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Integrated Hood | not stated | not stated |
| Placement | not stated | not stated | Outdoor | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Application | not stated | Camping | Camping | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Material | not stated | Stainless Steel | not stated | not stated | Stainless Steel | not stated | Cast Iron |
| Included Accessories | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Cover | not stated |
| Compatible Appliance | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle |
| Size | 28" x 17" x 2.5" | not stated | not stated | 28 Inch | 22 Inches | 22.3" x 16.8" x 1" | 12.6" x 8.6" x 0.5" |
| Cover | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Hood | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 20 × 3 × 8 inches | not stated | 19.4 × 23.8 × 9.56 inches | 22.8 × 44 × 33 inches | 23.6 × 23.6 × 13 inches | 22.3 × 16.8 × 0.98 inches | 12.6 × 8.6 × 0.5 inches |
| Weight | 34.7 pounds | not stated | 18.4 pounds | 69 pounds | 37.5 pounds | 1.43 pounds | not stated |
| Color | Black | Silver | Black | Black | Black | Orange 22 inch | Black |
| Model | not stated | not stated | CGG-9291 | 1517 | 1813 | Silicone Griddle Mat | 6558 6559 |
Another guide worth a look: temprium 28 alternatives.
Frequently asked questions
Is the BBQration 28-inch top compatible with Camp Chef griddles?
No. The BBQration replacement is designed specifically for standard 28-inch Blackstone griddles. If you own a Camp Chef FTG600 or FTG900PG, you should look at the Stanbroil stainless steel option instead. It is listed as a direct fit for those specific Camp Chef models.
How heavy is the replacement griddle top?
The BBQration 28-inch replacement top weighs 34.7 pounds. This heavy steel plate helps reduce warping during high-heat cooking. In comparison, the Cuisinart tabletop model is much lighter at 18.4 pounds, while the full Blackstone Omnivore unit weighs 69 pounds.
Does the Stanbroil top require seasoning?
No. The Stanbroil 28-inch top is made of stainless steel, which is corrosion-resistant. Unlike the carbon steel BBQration plate, this surface does not require the initial seasoning process. This makes it a lower-maintenance choice for Camp Chef owners.
What are the dimensions of the Cuisinart tabletop griddle?
The Cuisinart 17-inch tabletop gas griddle measures 23.8 inches wide, 19.4 inches long, and 9.56 inches high. It is designed for small groups and portable outdoor events. It is not suitable for large family cookouts that require extensive cooking space.
Is the Blackstone Omnivore portable?
No. The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle weighs 69 pounds and measures 44 inches wide. It is built for large-capacity stationary outdoor cooking. You should only choose this if you have a permanent outdoor kitchen setup and do not need to move the unit.
Does the Blackstone 22-inch model include a cover?
Yes. The Blackstone Original 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle comes with a protective hood. This feature helps shield the cooking surface when not in use. It is ideal for compact outdoor cooking with two heat zones in portable setups.
What is the Protebox mat used for?
The Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat is designed to protect 22-inch griddle surfaces. It measures 22.3 inches by 16.8 inches. This accessory is the right pick if you prioritize rust prevention and easy storage over full-size coverage for larger units.
Can the Uniflasy griddle replace my main grill?
No. The Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle is a small accessory for Weber Q series grills. It measures 12.6 inches by 8.6 inches. It fits those who need a small flat top for side dishes or breakfast foods, but it does not replace the main grill for large meals.