BLACKSTONE Blackstone® 1517 Original 28" Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

Comparing Griddle Specs and Features

Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top

The Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top measures 36 inches by 20.5 inches with a height of 3 inches. It is made of stainless steel, which differs from the original Blackstone's carbon steel construction. This unit is designed as a replacement griddle top for specific Blackstone 36-inch models. It does not include a frame, legs, or burners. You must already own a compatible frame to use this surface. The stainless steel material offers different heat retention and durability characteristics compared to the original Omnivore plate. This pick suits owners of larger Blackstone frames who want to upgrade their cooking surface material without replacing the entire unit. It provides a large cooking area but lacks the integrated mobility and fuel system of the original standalone griddle.

Napoleon Stainless Steel Griddle Insert

The Napoleon Stainless Steel Griddle Insert measures 28.2 inches by 18.3 inches with a height of 3.2 inches. It weighs 26.1 pounds. This insert is built for stainless steel construction and is designed to fit inside compatible Prestige or Rogue gas grills. It is a built-in form factor, meaning it is not a standalone unit like the original Blackstone 28-inch griddle. You cannot use this insert without a specific Napoleon grill frame. It provides a large, even-heating surface for versatile outdoor cooking but lacks the independent propane system and portability of the original. This pick is for users who already own a compatible Napoleon grill and want to expand its cooking capabilities. It offers a different material and integration method compared to the original standalone propane griddle.

Blackstone 28-Inch 2-Burner Omnivore Griddle

The Blackstone 28-Inch 2-Burner Omnivore Griddle measures 46.5 inches by 21.9 inches with a height of 33.7 inches. It is a portable propane griddle with a black finish. This model features two burners, providing independent heat zones for outdoor cooking. It is larger in width than the original 28-inch model, which measures 44 inches wide. The height is slightly greater at 33.7 inches compared to the original's 33 inches. It is designed for large outdoor gatherings and uses propane as its fuel type. This pick suits users who need more precise heat control through independent burners. It offers a similar Omnivore griddle plate technology but with a different burner configuration and slightly larger footprint. The portable design remains consistent with the original, allowing for easy movement via wheels.

Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle

The Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle measures 50 inches by 29 inches with a height of 37 inches. It weighs 110 pounds. This unit features a ceramic cooking surface and is powered by gas or propane. It is a portable griddle with a hard cover included. The ceramic material offers different heat distribution and cleanup properties compared to the original Blackstone's steel plate. It is significantly heavier at 110 pounds versus the original's 69 pounds. The dimensions are larger, providing ample heat and space for large outdoor cooking. This pick suits users who value easy cleanup and a covered design for patios or campsites. It lacks the Omnivore griddle plate technology but offers a covered, portable alternative with a ceramic surface. The included cover provides weather protection, which the original model does not specify.

Blackstone 22-Inch Griddle with Hood and Stand

The Blackstone 22-Inch Griddle with Hood and Stand measures 66.5 inches by 26.8 inches with a height of 36.5 inches. It is a portable outdoor griddle with a powder-coated black finish. This model includes a hood for wind protection and independent burner control. It is designed for camping and portable outdoor cooking. The dimensions are different from the original 28-inch model, with a larger width but smaller cooking surface area implied by the 22-inch size. It lacks the Omnivore griddle plate technology of the original but offers a compact footprint for campers. This pick suits those who value wind protection and independent burner control in a smaller package. It is a standalone unit with a stand, providing portability similar to the original but with a different size and feature set focused on camping utility.

Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood

The Blackstone Original 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hood measures 23.6 inches by 23.6 inches with a height of 13 inches. It weighs 37.5 pounds. This unit is a tabletop griddle with a black finish and a hood. It is designed for portable tabletop outdoor cooking. The size is significantly smaller than the original 28-inch model, which measures 44 inches wide. The height is lower at 13 inches compared to the original's 33 inches. It features dual heating zones for portable cooking. This pick suits buyers who need a compact, covered griddle for tabletop use. It lacks the large cooking area and height of the original Omnivore griddle. The tabletop form factor makes it distinct from the standalone, wheeled original. It is lighter and more portable, suitable for users who prioritize compact storage and tabletop convenience over large-scale outdoor cooking capacity.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle

Best for: Large outdoor family cooking sessions

Cooking Area

517 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane

Burners

2

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

22.8 × 44 × 33 inches

Weight

69 pounds

View on Amazon: Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle

The Blackstone 1517 Original is a 28-inch outdoor griddle offering 517 square inches of cooking space. It features a durable steel construction with a height of 33 inches and weighs 69 pounds. The unit includes side shelves for prep, a rear grease management system, and caster wheels for mobility. This model suits you if you need a large, stable cooking surface for family meals or entertaining guests outdoors.

Pros

• 517 square inch cooking area for large batches
• Omnivore griddle plate for better heat distribution
• Rear grease management system for easy cleanup
• Caster wheels and side handle for mobility

Cons

• 69 pound weight requires effort to move
• No built-in temperature control knobs visible
• Only 1-year limited warranty coverage

Good fit if

• You need a large 517 square inch surface
• You want a stable 33 inch height
• You prefer rear grease management

Skip if

• You need a portable tabletop unit
• You want a stainless steel top
• You require a longer warranty

Verdict: Blackstone 28 Inch Original Omnivore Griddle is a solid choice for cooks who prioritize a large 517 square inch cooking area and efficient heat recovery. It fits outdoor kitchens where space and stability matter more than portability.

2 Best premium

Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top

Best for: Upgrading compatible Blackstone 36-inch griddles

Cooking Area

742 sq. in.

Surface Material

Stainless Steel

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

36 × 20.5 × 3 inches

View on Amazon: Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top

This is a replacement griddle top for select Blackstone 36-inch models, not a standalone unit. It features a 742 square inch stainless steel surface and measures 36 by 20.5 inches. The thickened steel resists warping. A full-width rear grease trough helps manage flare-ups. It suits owners needing a durable upgrade for compatible Blackstone grills.

Pros

• 742 square inch stainless steel cooking area
• Compatible with 14 specific Blackstone 36-inch models
• Full-width rear grease trough with drain
• Thickened steel construction resists warping

Cons

• Only fits specific Blackstone 36-inch models
• Not a standalone cooking unit
• Requires compatible Blackstone frame

Good fit if

• You own a compatible Blackstone 36-inch griddle
• You want a stainless steel surface
• You need a large replacement top

Skip if

• You need a standalone griddle
• You have a different Blackstone size
• You prefer non-stick coating

Verdict: Stanbroil 36" Stainless Steel Replacement Griddle fits owners of specific Blackstone 36-inch models who want a durable stainless steel surface. It provides a large cooking area with improved grease management for those upgrading their existing frame.

3 Best built-in

Napoleon Stainless Steel Griddle Insert

Best for: expanding compatible grill capabilities

Fuel Type

Grill Insert

Surface Material

Stainless Steel

Form Factor

Insert Top

Cooking Dimensions

26" x 16"

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

3.2 × 28.2 × 18.3 inches

View on Amazon: Napoleon Stainless Steel Griddle Insert

This Napoleon insert transforms compatible gas grills into a full-sized griddle. It features a 26 by 16 inch cooking surface made of thick stainless steel for even heat. The unit weighs 26.1 pounds and measures 28.2 inches wide. It is designed for Prestige and Rogue series models. You get a versatile surface for searing and stir-frying. This built-in accessory expands your outdoor cooking options without needing a separate appliance.

Pros

• 26 x 16 inch stainless steel cooking surface
• Thick construction for even heat performance
• Quick installation and removal for conversion
• Compatible with Prestige and Rogue gas grills

Cons

• Requires a specific compatible grill model
• Limited to built-in installation only
• No separate fuel source included

Good fit if

• You own a compatible Prestige or Rogue grill
• You want to add griddle cooking to an existing setup
• You prefer stainless steel surfaces for easy cleaning

Skip if

• You do not have a compatible gas grill
• You need a standalone portable griddle
• You prefer cast iron cooking surfaces

Verdict: Napoleon Stainless Steel Griddle Insert is a practical upgrade for owners of compatible Prestige or Rogue gas grills. It provides a large, even-heating surface for versatile outdoor cooking without requiring a separate unit.

4 Best budget

Blackstone 28-Inch 2-Burner Omnivore Griddle

Best for: large outdoor gatherings with propane

Cooking Area

527 sq in

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

2

Placement

Outdoor

Form Factor

Portable

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

View on Amazon: Blackstone 28-Inch 2-Burner Omnivore Griddle

The Blackstone 28 inch Omnivore griddle offers 527 square inches of cooking space powered by two independent propane burners. Its patented plate technology aims for even heating and reduced warping. The unit includes a side shelf with tool hooks and a rear grease management system. Two wheels and a handle provide portability for outdoor use.

Pros

• 527 square inch cooking area
• Two independently controlled burners
• Patented Omnivore plate technology
• Integrated grease management system
• Side shelf with tool hooks

Cons

• Requires propane gas fuel
• Standard black finish
• No app or remote control

Good fit if

• You need a large cooking surface for groups
• You want independent temperature zones
• You prefer portable outdoor cooking

Skip if

• You require electric power only
• You need a tabletop model
• You want stainless steel construction

Verdict: Blackstone 28" Omnivore Griddle fits you if you need a spacious, portable propane griddle with independent heat zones for outdoor cooking.

5 Best ceramic

Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle

Best for: Large outdoor cooking with easy cleanup

Cooking Area

421 square inches

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

2

Total Heat Output

26,000 BTU

Surface Material

Ceramic Coated

Cooking Dimensions

23" L x 18" W

View on Amazon: Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle

This Pit Boss unit offers 421 square inches of cooking space with a non-stick ceramic surface. It uses two stainless steel burners to deliver 26,000 BTU of heat. The lift-off top weighs 55 pounds and folds for storage. It includes folding side shelves and a hard cover. You get a practical outdoor cooking solution that balances portability with substantial heat output for your meals.

Pros

• 421 square inches of ceramic cooking area
• 26,000 BTU total heat output from two burners
• Non-stick armored ceramic surface for easy cleaning
• Includes a hard cover for protection
• Folding side shelves with tool hooks

Cons

• Heavy at 110 pounds total
• Large footprint at 50 inches long
• No digital temperature control listed

Good fit if

• You need a large cooking surface for groups
• You prefer non-stick ceramic over bare steel
• You want a portable unit with a hard cover

Skip if

• You require precise digital temperature monitoring
• You have limited storage space for a 50-inch unit
• You prefer a lightweight tabletop griddle

Verdict: Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle provides ample heat and a large ceramic surface for outdoor cooking. It suits you if you value easy cleanup and a covered, portable design for your patio or campsite.

6 Best camping

Blackstone 22-Inch Griddle with Hood and Stand

Best for: camping and portable outdoor cooking

Cooking Area

768 sq in

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

4

Surface Material

Cold Rolled Steel

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Built-in Hood

View on Amazon: Blackstone 22-Inch Griddle with Hood and Stand

This tabletop griddle offers 768 square inches of cold rolled steel cooking space. It features four independent burners for precise heat control and a built-in hood for wind protection. The foldable side shelves and wheels make it portable for camping or outdoor use. You get a grease management system and included accessories for easier maintenance and seasoning.

Pros

• 768 square inch cold rolled steel surface
• Four independent burners for zone cooking
• Built-in hood blocks wind and retains heat
• Foldable side shelves for compact storage
• Integrated grease management system

Cons

• Tabletop form factor limits stability on uneven ground
• Cold rolled steel requires regular seasoning to prevent rust
• No mention of digital temperature controls or ignition type

Good fit if

• You need a portable setup for camping trips
• You want independent heat zones for different foods
• You prefer a compact unit with folding shelves

Skip if

• You require a permanent outdoor kitchen installation
• You need a non-stick ceramic coating
• You want a larger cooking area than 768 sq in

Verdict: Blackstone 22" Portable Griddle with Hood provides a balanced mix of portability and cooking power for campers. It suits those who value independent burner control and wind protection in a compact footprint.

7 Best tabletop

Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood

Best for: portable tabletop outdoor cooking

Cooking Area

361 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane

Burners

2

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Integrated Hood

Material

Stainless Steel

View on Amazon: Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood

This tabletop griddle offers 361 square inches of cooking space across a 22-inch surface. It features two independently heated zones for versatile cooking and a piezo ignition for easy starts. The unit includes an integrated hood for protection and a rear grease management system for cleanup. Weighing 37.5 pounds, it is designed for portability to tailgates or camping. It suits those needing a compact, durable outdoor cooking surface.

Pros

• 361 square inches of cooking area
• Two independently heated zones
• Integrated protective hood
• Piezo ignition system

Cons

• Smaller surface area than 28-inch models
• Heavier than many portable options
• No remote control or app connectivity

Good fit if

• You need a compact griddle for tailgating
• You want two separate cooking temperatures
• You prefer a covered surface for protection

Skip if

• You require a full-size 28-inch surface
• You need smart home integration
• You want a lightweight travel unit

Verdict: Blackstone 22 Inch Tabletop Griddle fits buyers who need a compact, covered griddle with dual heating zones for portable outdoor cooking.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• de longhi nespresso lattissima one original alternatives
• tribest greenstar gs 1000 original slow alternatives