6 Best Alternatives to the Onlyfire Stainless Steel Cooking Grate (2026)

How each alternative compares

QuliMetal 19-Inch Tabletop Multi-Fuel Grill

The QuliMetal 19-Inch Tabletop Grill differs significantly from the Onlyfire grate by being a standalone portable unit rather than a kamado accessory. It weighs 10.5 pounds and measures 17.7 inches long, making it ideal for camping or tailgating where portability matters more than fixed installation. While the Onlyfire system requires an 18-inch Kamado Joe Classic to function, this QuliMetal grill operates independently using charcoal. It offers a stainless steel construction similar to the Onlyfire grate but provides a complete cooking surface without needing a larger grill body. You lose the indirect cooking versatility of the Onlyfire deflectors, but gain a self-contained, rustproof option for outdoor events away from home.

ADREAK 2-Burner 17.3-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle

The ADREAK 2-Burner Gas Griddle is a gas-powered alternative to the charcoal-dependent Onlyfire system. It features a 17.3-inch stainless steel flat top powered by propane, contrasting with the Onlyfire grate’s use of ceramic deflectors and charcoal heat. This unit weighs less than the Onlyfire kit and is designed for portable tabletop use. It provides high, consistent heat for flat-top cooking, whereas the Onlyfire system is built for indirect roasting and baking inside a kamado. You give up the ability to smoke or roast large cuts using the kamado method, but you gain easy temperature control and quick cleanup. This choice suits users who prioritize speed and versatility over traditional kamado indirect cooking techniques.

Kamado Joe Classic Joe II 18-Inch Ceramic Charcoal Grill

The Kamado Joe Classic Joe II is a full 18-inch ceramic grill, whereas the Onlyfire product is merely an accessory kit for such grills. This complete unit weighs 232 pounds and includes side shelves, offering a permanent, heavy-duty solution for precision smoking and searing. It provides the entire cooking environment that the Onlyfire grate enhances, rather than just the grate itself. You gain professional-grade heat control and durability in a single package, but you sacrifice the modularity and lower cost of adding just a grate system. This option fits serious cooks with space for a large, substantial unit who want an all-in-one smoker and grill rather than an upgrade for an existing kamado.

GORGERILA 14-Inch Stainless Steel Charcoal Basket

The GORGERILA 14-Inch Charcoal Basket focuses on fuel management rather than cooking surface expansion. Designed for large Big Green Egg grills, it replaces the bottom ash collection method rather than providing a cooking grate. It is made of stainless steel, similar to the Onlyfire grate, but serves a different function by holding charcoal to save fuel and manage heat zones. You cannot cook directly on this basket; it sits below the cooking surface. This alternative is for users who already have a grate system but want better charcoal efficiency and easier ash cleanup. It complements a kamado setup rather than replacing the need for a cooking grate or deflectors.

GriAddict Large Kamado Charcoal Ash Basket

The GriAddict Large Kamado Ash Basket is another fuel management tool, weighing 4.25 pounds and designed for Kamado Joe Classic and Big Green Egg grills. Like the GORGERILA basket, it does not provide a cooking surface but instead improves airflow and ash removal. It fits your 18-inch grill perfectly, whereas the Onlyfire system adds cooking capacity. You gain easier maintenance and potentially better heat control through improved airflow, but you do not get the extended cooking area or indirect cooking setup provided by the Onlyfire grate and deflectors. This choice is best for kamado owners who prioritize efficient charcoal usage and quick cleanup over expanding their grilling surface area.

Kamado Joe 20-inch Ceramic Pizza Stone

The Kamado Joe 20-inch Ceramic Pizza Stone is a ceramic accessory for Kamado Joe Big Joe grills, differing from the stainless steel Onlyfire grate system. It measures 20 inches wide and 0.31 inches thick, providing a dedicated surface for baking pizzas with even heat distribution. Unlike the Onlyfire kit, which includes deflectors and a base rack for versatile indirect cooking, this stone is specialized for pizza crusts. It is made of ceramic rather than stainless steel, offering different thermal properties. You gain a durable, specialized surface for crispy crusts, but you lose the multi-purpose cooking flexibility of the Onlyfire system. This option suits Big Joe owners who prioritize pizza quality over general grilling versatility.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Onlyfire 18-Inch Stainless Steel Cooking Grate System

Best for: indirect cooking in 18-inch kamado grills

Material

Stainless Steel

Style

Kamado

Weight

14.2 pounds

View on Amazon: Onlyfire 18-Inch Stainless Steel Cooking Grate System Affiliate link

This Onlyfire kit includes two half-moon grates, a base rack, and two split ceramic deflectors. It is designed for 18-inch Kamado Joe Classic grills. The stainless steel construction supports indirect cooking. You can roast large items like ribs or pizza simultaneously. The system weighs 14.2 pounds. It fits other large kamado grills like the Big Green Egg. This setup expands your cooking surface for versatile meal preparation.

Pros

• Includes two half-moon stainless steel grates
• Comes with two split ceramic heat deflectors
• Adds a base rack for stability
• Supports indirect cooking for whole roasts

Cons

• Heavier than standard grates at 14.2 pounds
• Requires specific 18-inch kamado dimensions
• No mention of dishwasher-safe components

Good fit if

• You own an 18-inch Kamado Joe Classic
• You want to cook large cuts of meat
• You need a versatile indirect cooking setup

Skip if

• You have a 22-inch Weber Kettle Grill
• You prefer lightweight portable accessories
• You need a single-piece grate design

Verdict: Onlyfire Stainless Steel Grate for 18" Kamado provides a complete indirect cooking system for large kamado owners. It is ideal for those who roast whole chickens or bake pizzas regularly.

2 Also great

QuliMetal 19-Inch Tabletop Multi-Fuel Grill

Best for: portable camping and tailgate grilling

Fuel Type

Charcoal, wood, gas

Heat Output

5,000 BTU

Burner Count

1

Form Factor

Portable tabletop

Primary Material

Stainless steel

Application

Camping, Backyard, Tailgating

View on Amazon: QuliMetal 19-Inch Tabletop Multi-Fuel Grill Affiliate link

This QuliMetal tabletop grill combines charcoal, wood, and a 5,000 BTU gas burner for flexible outdoor cooking. The 17.7-inch stainless steel surface includes a pull-out griddle plate for easy cleaning. Weighing 10.5 pounds, it folds for compact storage. It suits campers and tailgaters who need a versatile, rustproof unit for small groups.

Pros

• Triple fuel compatibility with charcoal, wood, and 5,000 BTU gas
• Pull-out removable griddle plate simplifies grease cleanup
• Heavy-duty stainless steel construction resists rust and corrosion
• Foldable design fits easily in car trunks or backpacks

Cons

• Smaller cooking surface than standard backyard grills
• Propane cylinder not included
• Requires manual ignition with a torch lighter

Good fit if

• You need a portable grill for camping or tailgating
• You want to switch between charcoal and gas fuel
• You prefer stainless steel that resists outdoor rust

Skip if

• You require a large surface for big family gatherings
• You want an integrated electronic ignition system
• You need a permanent outdoor kitchen fixture

Verdict: QuliMetal Portable Stainless Steel Grill offers versatile fuel options and easy cleanup for campers and tailgaters. It fits buyers who prioritize portability and rustproof construction over high-volume cooking capacity.

3 Best propane

ADREAK 2-Burner 17.3-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle

Best for: portable outdoor flat-top cooking

Fuel Type

Propane

Cooking Area

285.5 sq. in.

Heat Output

30,000 BTU

Burner Count

2

Form Factor

Tabletop

Primary Material

Stainless steel

View on Amazon: ADREAK 2-Burner 17.3-Inch Tabletop Gas Griddle Affiliate link

The ADREAK 2-burner griddle offers 285.5 square inches of stainless steel cooking space. It delivers 30,000 BTUs from two individual burners for fast heating. The enamel coating resists rust and improves thermal conductivity. You get a tabletop design with a removable hood to retain heat. This propane unit is portable and easy to clean with slide-out grease cups.

Pros

• 285.5 square inches of stainless steel cooking area
• 30,000 BTU heat output from 2 burners
• Enamel coating prevents rust and aids conductivity
• Removable hood retains heat for faster cooking
• Slide-out grease cups simplify cleanup

Cons

• Tabletop form factor requires a stable surface
• Manual piezo ignition lacks electronic precision
• No remote or digital temperature display

Good fit if

• You need ample space for family meals
• You prefer portable tabletop setups
• You want easy cleanup with removable parts

Skip if

• You require built-in installation
• You need digital temperature controls
• You prefer ceramic cooking surfaces

Verdict: ADREAK 17.3-Inch 2-Burner Gas Griddle is a practical choice for campers and tailgaters who need high heat and a large flat top. It fits users who prioritize portability and easy maintenance over advanced digital features.

4 Best premium

Kamado Joe Classic Joe II 18-Inch Ceramic Charcoal Grill

Best for: Precision smoking and high-heat searing

Fuel Type

Charcoal

Cooking Area

250 sq. in.

Form Factor

Cart

Primary Material

Ceramic

Temperature Range

225F - 750F

Features

Side Shelf

View on Amazon: Kamado Joe Classic Joe II 18-Inch Ceramic Charcoal Grill Affiliate link

This 18-inch ceramic charcoal grill offers 250 square inches of cooking space. It features a cast iron cart with locking wheels and an air lift hinge for easy dome handling. The Kontrol Tower vent manages airflow from 225F to 750F. You get precise temperature control and durable construction. It suits those seeking high-heat searing and low-and-slow smoking capabilities in a single unit.

Pros

• 18-inch ceramic body with 250 sq. in. cooking area
• Air lift hinge reduces dome weight for one-finger lifting
• Kontrol Tower top vent maintains precise airflow
• Temperature range spans 225F to 750F

Cons

• Weighs 232 pounds, making it difficult to move
• Requires charcoal fuel, limiting portability
• Large footprint requires dedicated outdoor space

Good fit if

• You want precise temperature control for smoking
• You need high-heat searing up to 750F
• You have space for a heavy, permanent grill

Skip if

• You prefer propane or gas fuel
• You need a lightweight, portable grill
• You have limited outdoor space

Verdict: Kamado Joe Classic II 18-inch Ceramic Grill delivers professional-grade heat control and durability. It fits serious cooks who value precision and have the space for a substantial, heavy-duty unit.

5 Best budget

GORGERILA 14-Inch Stainless Steel Charcoal Basket

Best for: Large kamado grill charcoal management

Primary Material

Stainless Steel

Fuel Type

Charcoal

Style

Kamado

View on Amazon: GORGERILA 14-Inch Stainless Steel Charcoal Basket Affiliate link

This stainless steel charcoal ash basket fits Large Big Green Egg and Kamado Joe Classic grills. It measures 14 inches at the top and 9 inches at the bottom. The design includes a removable divider to create focused cooking zones. This feature helps cut charcoal waste by half for small meals. The wire gaps retain small charcoal while allowing free airflow. You can easily shake out ash to reuse charcoal chunks.

Pros

• Precision-welded stainless steel construction for durability
• Removable divider enables focused cooking zones
• Reduces charcoal waste by 50% for small meals
• Chamfered wire ends protect hands from cuts

Cons

• Specifically sized for large kamado grills
• No included ash removal tool
• Manual shaking required for cleaning

Good fit if

• You own a Large Big Green Egg or similar 18-inch kamado grill
• You want to reuse charcoal chunks by separating them from ash
• You need precise heat control for indirect cooking

Skip if

• You use a standard charcoal grill that is not a kamado style
• You prefer a smaller ash basket for compact grills
• You want an ash basket with a built-in handle for easy lifting

Verdict: GORGERILA 14-Inch Stainless Steel Ash Basket provides a durable solution for large kamado grill owners. It helps you save charcoal and manage heat zones effectively. This basket is ideal for users who prioritize material quality and precise fuel management.

6 Best large

GriAddict Large Kamado Charcoal Ash Basket

Best for: Kamado Joe Classic and Big Green Egg

Fuel Type

Charcoal

Material

Stainless Steel

Style

Kamado

Size

Large

Weight

4.25 pounds

View on Amazon: GriAddict Large Kamado Charcoal Ash Basket Affiliate link

This GriAddict ash basket is designed for 18-inch kamado grills like the Kamado Joe Classic and Large Big Green Egg. It weighs 4.25 pounds and features a stainless steel bowl with a removable divider. The design promotes airflow for better heat control and allows you to separate ash from unburned charcoal easily. It is a durable replacement part for heavy charcoal use.

Pros

• Made of heavy-duty stainless steel for long-term durability
• Includes a stainless divider for two-zone cooking setup
• Bowl shape allows free air circulation from below and sides
• Fits 18-inch charcoal grills including Kamado Joe and Big Green Egg
• Shake-out design helps separate ash from remaining charcoal

Cons

• Limited to specific 18-inch kamado grill models
• Heavy at 4.25 pounds, which may be cumbersome to handle
• No mention of high-temperature coating or special finish

Good fit if

• You own a Kamado Joe Classic or Large Big Green Egg
• You want to manage two-zone cooking with a divider
• You prefer stainless steel over ceramic components

Skip if

• You use a smaller kamado or non-kamado grill
• You need a lightweight accessory for frequent transport
• You are looking for a primary cooking grate

Verdict: GriAddict Large Stainless Steel Ash Basket is a solid upgrade for kamado owners who want better airflow and easier ash management. It fits your 18-inch grill perfectly and helps you save charcoal.

7 Best ceramic

Kamado Joe 20-inch Ceramic Pizza Stone

Best for: Kamado Joe Big Joe grill users

Fuel Type

Charcoal

Material

Ceramic

Included Accessories

Pizza Stone

Style

Kamado

Compatible Appliance

Smoker

Dimensions

20 × 20 × 0.31 inches

View on Amazon: Kamado Joe 20-inch Ceramic Pizza Stone Affiliate link

This is a 20-inch ceramic pizza stone designed for brick-oven style cooking. It measures 20 by 20 inches with a thickness of 0.31 inches. The heavy-duty ceramic material distributes heat evenly and absorbs moisture for crispy results. It fits Kamado Joe Big Joe I, II, and III models. The stone weighs 9.59 pounds and is easy to clean.

Pros

• 20-inch diameter provides ample cooking space
• Heavy-duty ceramic construction for durability
• Even heat distribution and moisture absorption
• Compatible with Big Joe I, II, and III

Cons

• 9.59-pound weight makes it heavy to handle
• 0.31-inch thickness is thinner than deep dish stones
• Limited to Kamado Joe compatible grills only

Good fit if

• You own a Kamado Joe Big Joe grill
• You want even heat distribution for crispy crusts
• You prefer ceramic materials for moisture absorption

Skip if

• You need a stone for non-Kamado grills
• You require a deep dish pizza stone
• You want a lightweight accessory for travel

Verdict: Kamado Joe 20-inch Ceramic Pizza Stone is a solid choice for Kamado Joe Big Joe owners seeking even heat and crispy crusts. It fits users who prioritize ceramic durability and specific grill compatibility over versatility.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions