Looking Beyond the Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look

How Each Alternative Compares

Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hard Cover

The Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle shifts you from passive protection to active cooking. While the Protebox mat is a 1.43-pound silicone sheet designed to shield a surface, this unit is a 22-inch propane-powered appliance. It features dual heat zones and piezo ignition, allowing independent temperature control that a cover cannot provide. You gain the ability to cook food directly on the surface rather than protecting it. The included hard cover offers robust storage protection similar to the mat’s debris shielding. If you need to prepare meals outdoors rather than just maintain equipment, this griddle replaces the mat’s role with full cooking capability.

Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle

The Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle offers significantly more cooking capacity than the Protebox mat. Instead of a 22.3-inch silicone protector, you receive a 25-inch long, 30-pound gas-powered unit with a 316-square-inch cooking surface. This model provides portable high-heat outdoor cooking for tailgating, whereas the mat only prevents rust and stains. It lacks the fine fit of the mat on specific Blackstone surfaces but compensates with substantial heat output and width. You trade the lightweight, foldable nature of the silicone mat for a heavier, more powerful cooking station. Choose this if you prioritize cooking area and heat over simple surface protection.

Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid with Thermometer

The Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid with Thermometer serves as a functional upgrade for Blackstone owners rather than a replacement for the mat. It is a hard cover measuring 24 inches long by 18 inches wide, designed to fit compatible 22-inch griddles. Unlike the flexible silicone mat that lies flat, this lid provides wind protection and allows temperature monitoring via an integrated thermometer. It offers a secure fit for frequent outdoor cooks who need to check heat without lifting the entire cover. While the Protebox mat focuses on moisture and debris collection, this lid emphasizes heat retention and monitoring. It is a practical alternative if you need active cooking aids alongside surface protection.

Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle

The Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle is a massive departure from the lightweight Protebox mat. This 110-pound portable unit features a ceramic surface and measures 50 inches long by 29 inches wide. It provides a heavy-duty cooking area that dwarfs the 22.3-inch dimensions of the silicone mat. While the mat protects a specific griddle surface, this appliance brings its own cooking capability to any location. You gain a substantial cooking footprint and ceramic durability but sacrifice the ease of storage and the low profile of the mat. It is a robust choice for those who want a dedicated cooking station rather than a protective layer for an existing griddle.

Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle

The Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle targets large group cooking with a 753-square-inch surface. This 63-inch long, 29-inch wide unit is built for camping and tailgating, offering independent burner control. In contrast, the Protebox mat is a simple 1.43-pound silicone sheet for surface protection. You trade the mat’s simplicity for immense cooking power and space. The griddle requires significant storage space and effort to move, unlike the foldable mat. It is ideal for outdoor gatherings where cooking capacity matters more than protecting a single surface. If you need to feed many people, this unit replaces the mat’s protective role with active meal preparation.

Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle

The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle is a stationary solution for serious outdoor cooking. It features a massive 517-square-inch surface and weighs 69 pounds. This unit prioritizes cooking capacity and heat recovery over portability. The Protebox mat is designed for a 22-inch Blackstone griddle and weighs only 1.43 pounds. You lose the flexibility and lightweight nature of the mat when choosing this large appliance. However, you gain a dedicated, high-capacity cooking station that does not rely on an existing griddle. It is a better fit for users who want a permanent outdoor cooking setup rather than a protective accessory for a portable unit.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat

Best for: protecting Blackstone 22-inch griddle surfaces

Included Accessories

Cover

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

22.3 × 16.8 × 0.98 inches

Weight

1.43 pounds

View on Amazon: Protebox 22-Inch Silicone Griddle Mat Affiliate link

This is a 22-inch silicone griddle mat designed specifically for Blackstone tabletop griddles. It measures 22.3 inches by 16.8 inches with a height of 0.98 inches. The mat is made from heavy-duty food-grade silicone and weighs 1.43 pounds. It features a high-sided design to collect debris and moisture. You will find it useful for protecting your griddle surface from rust, dust, and insects when not in use.

Pros

• Specially designed for Blackstone 22-inch griddles for a snug fit
• Made from 100% food-grade silicone material
• High-sided design collects moisture and debris
• Non-stick surface is easy to clean
• Foldable and reusable for storage

Cons

• Only covers the cooking surface, not the entire unit
• Does not protect against rodents or insects underneath
• Requires manual placement and removal

Good fit if

• You own a Blackstone 22-inch tabletop griddle
• You want to prevent rust and oxidation on the cooking surface
• You prefer a flexible, easy-to-clean cover

Skip if

• You have a different griddle size or brand
• You need full enclosure protection for the entire unit
• You prefer a hard cover with a lid

Verdict: Protebox 22" Silicone Griddle Mat fits Blackstone 22-inch griddles perfectly to shield the cooking surface from rust and debris. It is a practical solution for owners who want to extend the life of their griddle with a flexible, easy-to-clean cover.

2 Also great

Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hard Cover

Best for: Dual-zone portable propane cooking

Fuel Type

Propane

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Hard Cover

Placement

Outdoor

Application

Camping, Backyard

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

View on Amazon: Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hard Cover Affiliate link

This Blackstone tabletop griddle features a 22-inch pre-seasoned cooking surface with two independent heat zones. It runs on propane and includes a hard cover for protection. The rear grease management system simplifies cleanup. You will appreciate the piezo ignition for reliable, battery-free lighting. This unit is designed for portable outdoor cooking at campsites or tailgates.

Pros

• 22-inch pre-seasoned griddle plate
• Dual independent heat zones
• Piezo ignition for battery-free lighting
• Includes protective hard cover
• Rear grease management channels

Cons

• Propane fuel requires tank refills
• No electronic temperature control
• Hard cover adds bulk for storage

Good fit if

• You want precise heat control for different foods
• You need reliable ignition without batteries
• You prefer durable hard cover protection

Skip if

• You require electric power sources only
• You need digital temperature displays
• You want a non-stick silicone mat

Verdict: Blackstone 22" Propane Tabletop Griddle offers dual heat zones and piezo ignition for versatile outdoor cooking. It suits those who value independent temperature control and durable, portable design.

3 Also great

Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle

Best for: portable high-heat outdoor cooking

Cooking Area

316 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

3

Total Heat Output

25,500 BTU

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Cover

View on Amazon: Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle Affiliate link

The Royal Gourmet PD1301R is a portable tabletop griddle powered by propane. It features three burners delivering 25,500 BTU of heat across a 316 square inch cooking surface. The unit includes a cover and a slide-out grease cup for easy cleanup. You will appreciate the instant piezo ignition and detachable griddle top. This setup suits small outdoor events where portability and quick assembly matter.

Pros

• 316 square inch cooking area
• 25,500 BTU total heat output
• Three separately controlled burners
• Includes protective cover

Cons

• Heavier at 30 pounds
• Requires 20 lb propane tank
• No independent temperature controls

Good fit if

• You need a large cooking surface
• You want portable tabletop cooking
• You prefer propane fuel

Skip if

• You need electric power only
• You want a non-stick mat
• You prefer lightweight gear

Verdict: Royal Gourmet 3-Burner 316 Sq In Griddle offers substantial cooking space and heat for tailgating. It fits buyers who prioritize capacity and portability over precise temperature zoning.

4 Best budget

Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid with Thermometer

Best for: Blackstone 22-inch griddle owners needing heat monitoring

Form Factor

Tabletop

Features

Thermometer

Included Accessories

Cover

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Cover

Hard Cover

Dimensions

24 × 18 × 5 inches

View on Amazon: Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid with Thermometer Affiliate link

This hard cover fits Blackstone 22-inch tabletop griddles like the Omnivore and Original models. It features a hinged design with a cool-touch handle, so you do not need to remove it. A built-in thermometer lets you check internal heat without lifting the lid. The stainless steel body protects your cooking surface from dust and weather. It also acts as a windbreak when open.

Pros

• Built-in round thermometer for precise heat monitoring
• Hinged design with silicone handle for easy access
• Heavy-gauge stainless steel construction for durability
• Fits pre-drilled holes with no extra drilling required

Cons

• Only compatible with specific Blackstone 22-inch models
• Does not cover griddles with side shelves attached
• Lacks a locking mechanism to secure the lid

Good fit if

• You own a Blackstone 22-inch Omnivore or Original griddle
• You want to monitor temperature without lifting the cover
• You prefer a hinged lid that stays attached

Skip if

• You use a griddle with side tables or shelves
• You need a cover for a 17-inch or 22-inch Omnivore Pro
• You want a universal fit for multiple griddle sizes

Verdict: Unidanho 22" Hinged Lid with Thermometer provides a secure fit for compatible Blackstone griddles while offering convenient temperature checks. It is a practical upgrade for owners who cook frequently outdoors and value wind protection.

5 Best ceramic

Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle

Best for: portable ceramic griddle cooking

Cooking Area

421 square inches

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

2

Total Heat Output

26,000 BTU

Surface Material

Ceramic Coated

Cooking Dimensions

23" L x 18" W

View on Amazon: Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle Affiliate link

This Pit Boss unit offers 421 square inches of cooking area with a proprietary non-stick armored ceramic surface. It delivers 26,000 BTU across two stainless steel gas burners. The design includes a lift-off cooking top and folding side shelves. It suits you if you want a durable, portable griddle with a ceramic finish that resists rust and simplifies cleanup compared to bare metal.

Pros

• 421 square inches of ceramic-coated cooking space
• 26,000 BTU total heat output from two burners
• Lift-off cooking top for easier cleaning
• Includes hard cover and folding side shelves

Cons

• Weighs 110 pounds, making it heavy to move
• Measures 50 inches long, requiring significant space
• No electronic ignition or digital temperature control listed

Good fit if

• You prefer a ceramic surface over silicone mats or bare steel
• You need a portable unit with a hard cover for protection
• You want a lift-off top for easier maintenance

Skip if

• You require a lightweight unit under 50 pounds
• You have limited storage space for a 50-inch appliance
• You only need a simple silicone mat for an existing griddle

Verdict: Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle fits you if you want a heavy-duty, portable griddle with a ceramic surface that offers more cooking area than a silicone mat. It is a substantial unit that demands space and effort to move.

6 Best premium

Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle

Best for: large group outdoor cooking and tailgating

Cooking Area

753 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

4

Total Heat Output

62,000 BTU

Cooking Dimensions

37" x 20"

Cover Type

Hard Cover

View on Amazon: Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle Affiliate link

This Pit Boss unit offers 753 square inches of cooking space with a 37 by 20 inch surface. It uses four separately controlled stainless steel burners to deliver 62,000 BTU of heat. The 4.7mm thick griddle top retains temperature well. Folding side shelves and a hard cover make it portable for camping or tailgating. It is designed for you if you need a large, powerful outdoor cooking station that packs away easily.

Pros

• 753 square inch cooking area measures 37 by 20 inches
• 4 separately controlled stainless steel burners provide 62,000 BTU
• 4.7mm thick griddle surface ensures even heat distribution
• Folding side shelves with tool hooks aid portability
• Hard cover doubles as a windscreen for the griddle

Cons

• Total width of 63 inches requires significant storage space
• Height of 37 inches may be too tall for some users
• Propane fuel requires carrying tanks to your cooking spot

Good fit if

• You need a large cooking surface for groups
• You want independent control over four heat zones
• You need a durable hard cover for protection

Skip if

• You have limited storage space for a large unit
• You prefer electric or charcoal cooking methods
• You want a compact tabletop griddle under 22 inches

Verdict: Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle fits you if you prioritize a massive 753 square inch cooking area and independent burner control for outdoor gatherings. It is a robust choice for camping or tailgating where power and space matter more than portability.

7 Also great

Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle

Best for: large capacity outdoor cooking

Cooking Area

517 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane

Burners

2

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

22.8 × 44 × 33 inches

Weight

69 pounds

View on Amazon: Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle Affiliate link

This is a 28-inch propane griddle with a 517-square-inch cooking surface. It features a specialized Omnivore plate for faster preheat and better heat distribution. The unit includes side shelves for prep space and a rear grease management system. Weighing 69 pounds, it moves on caster wheels. It suits those needing a large, dedicated outdoor cooking station with ample workspace and efficient heat recovery.

Pros

• 517 square inch cooking area
• Omnivore griddle plate for efficient heat
• Built-in wind guards and faster recovery
• Side shelves for food prep
• Rear grease management system

Cons

• 69-pound weight requires effort to move
• 44-inch width needs significant space
• No app or remote control connectivity

Good fit if

• You need a large 517 sq. in. cooking surface
• You want dedicated side shelves for prep
• You prefer efficient heat recovery times

Skip if

• You need a portable unit under 50 pounds
• You have limited counter space less than 44 inches
• You want smart app connectivity

Verdict: Blackstone 28 Inch Omnivore Griddle fits users who prioritize a massive 517-square-inch cooking surface and efficient heat recovery over portability. It is a stationary solution for serious outdoor cooking.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions