SafBbcue 22-Inch Griddle Replacement Top Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

How these alternatives compare

BBQration 22-Inch Carbon Steel Griddle Top

The BBQration 22-Inch Carbon Steel Griddle Top offers a 4mm surface thickness, which may provide better heat retention than the SafBbcue unit. It weighs 19.6 pounds, making it slightly lighter than the 21.8-pound SafBbcue replacement. Both share the same 22 by 16.5 by 2.5 inch footprint, ensuring a direct swap for standard Blackstone tabletop griddles. However, the BBQration unit uses raw carbon steel, requiring you to season it before first use. The SafBbcue top arrives coated in cooking oil for protection. If you prefer the traditional feel of raw steel and do not mind the initial seasoning process, this budget-friendly option is a solid choice. Verify that your existing hood fits this replacement before purchasing.

Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood

The Blackstone Original 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hood is a complete unit rather than a replacement part. It weighs 37.5 pounds, significantly more than the 21.8-pound SafBbcue top. This model includes a hood for protection and features dual-zone cooking capabilities. It is designed for buyers who need a fresh, portable cooking station rather than those replacing a worn surface on an existing frame. The dimensions are 23.6 by 13 by 23.6 inches, differing from the flat replacement top. If your current griddle frame is intact and you only need a new surface, this complete unit is unnecessary. However, if you want an enclosed cooking experience with dual zones, this premium option provides a comprehensive solution for outdoor cooking.

Uniflasy 25x16 Cast Iron Griddle Insert

The Uniflasy 25x16 Cast Iron Griddle Insert is a cast iron unit measuring 25 by 16 by 3.2 inches. It is wider and longer than the SafBbcue 22-inch replacement, which measures 22 by 16.5 by 2.5 inches. This insert is designed to fit over existing grill grates, expanding your cooking space rather than replacing a griddle top. It weighs more due to the cast iron construction, offering superior heat retention. The SafBbcue top is a direct fit for Blackstone frames, while the Uniflasy insert requires a compatible outdoor grill. Choose this option if you want to add extra cooking area to a gas or charcoal grill. It is not a replacement for a broken Blackstone top but an accessory for expanding your current setup.

Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hood

The Blackstone 22-Inch OTG Griddle is a full tabletop unit weighing 49 pounds, much heavier than the 21.8-pound SafBbcue replacement. It measures 26 by 20 by 15 inches and includes a hood. This model is built for permanent or semi-permanent outdoor setups where weight is not a primary constraint. It features dual zones for flexible cooking. The SafBbcue top is a lightweight swap for existing frames. If you need a new cooking surface for your current Blackstone frame, this complete unit is too large and heavy. However, if you are starting fresh and want a robust, enclosed griddle with dual zones, this premium option delivers a complete cooking station. It is not suitable for those seeking a simple part replacement.

Blackstone 22-Inch OTG Dual-Zone Propane Griddle

The Blackstone 22-Inch OTG Dual-Zone Propane Griddle is a complete propane-powered unit. It is designed for portable tabletop cooking with dual-zone flexibility. Unlike the SafBbcue replacement top, which requires an existing frame and heat source, this unit is self-contained. It features battery-free ignition for easy startup. The SafBbcue top is a 21.8-pound part that fits specific Blackstone models. This Blackstone unit is a full appliance. Choose this option if you need a complete, portable cooking system with independent zone control. It is not a replacement part for a broken griddle. If your current frame is functional and you only need a new surface, the SafBbcue top is the appropriate choice. This unit is for buyers seeking a new, complete outdoor cooking experience.

Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Gas Griddle

The Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Gas Griddle is a portable gas unit weighing 27.6 pounds. It is slightly heavier than the SafBbcue replacement top. This griddle features three independent burners for precise temperature control across a 24-inch surface. The SafBbcue top is a 22-inch replacement part for existing frames. The Royal Gourmet unit is a complete cooking station with its own heat source. It is ideal for buyers who prioritize mobility and independent burner control. It does not fit into a Blackstone frame. If you need a new surface for your current griddle, this unit is incompatible. However, if you want a portable, self-contained griddle with ample space and zone control, this option offers a versatile outdoor cooking solution.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

SafBbcue 22-Inch Griddle Replacement Top

Best for: replacing worn tops on standard Blackstone griddles

Form Factor

Replacement Top

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

1 × 3 × 2 inches

Weight

21.8 pounds

View on Amazon: SafBbcue 22-Inch Griddle Replacement Top Affiliate link

This SafBbcue part is a 22-inch replacement top for Blackstone tabletop griddles. It measures 22 by 16.5 inches with a 2.5-inch depth. The unit weighs 21.8 pounds and fits models like the 1813 and 1666. You get a flat cooking surface designed for even heat. It is a direct swap for worn tops, not a full grill.

Pros

• 22-inch width matches standard Blackstone tabletop griddles
• Weighs 21.8 pounds for stable cooking
• Compatible with rear grease system models
• Includes cooking oil protection layer

Cons

• Does not fit Blackstone 22-inch combo grills
• Lid compatibility is not guaranteed
• Surface color may vary upon arrival

Good fit if

• You need a direct replacement for a worn Blackstone top
• You own a standard 22-inch tabletop griddle with a rear grease system
• You want a heavy-duty 21.8-pound steel surface

Skip if

• You own a Blackstone 22-inch combo grill
• You need a complete grill with burners and hood
• You require a lid that is confirmed to fit

Verdict: SafBbcue 22-Inch Replacement Griddle Top is a sturdy swap for owners of standard Blackstone tabletop griddles who need a fresh cooking surface. It fits the 1813 and 1666 models perfectly but will not work for combo units.

2 Best budget

BBQration 22-Inch Carbon Steel Griddle Top

Best for: Blackstone 22-inch griddle replacement

Cooking Area

361 square inches

Surface Material

Carbon Steel

Form Factor

Griddle Top

Dimensions

15 × 3 × 8 inches

Weight

19.6 pounds

View on Amazon: BBQration 22-Inch Carbon Steel Griddle Top Affiliate link

This is a replacement griddle top for Blackstone 22-inch models. It measures 22 by 16.5 inches with a 4mm thick carbon steel surface. The design includes a back X-shape to reduce warping. You get 361 square inches of cooking space. It weighs 19.6 pounds. You need to season it before use. It fits models like the 1666 and 1813.

Pros

• 4mm thick carbon steel construction
• 361 square inches of cooking area
• Back X-shape design reduces warping
• Compatible with multiple Blackstone 22-inch models

Cons

• Requires manual seasoning before first use
• May not fit original hoods exactly
• No chemical nonstick coating on surface

Good fit if

• You own a Blackstone 22-inch tabletop griddle
• You want a durable replacement top
• You prefer raw carbon steel surfaces

Skip if

• You need a complete griddle unit
• You want a pre-seasoned surface
• You have a different size griddle

Verdict: BBQration 22" Carbon Steel Griddle Top offers a sturdy 4mm surface for Blackstone owners. It suits those who want to maintain their existing frame and prefer raw steel. You should verify your hood fit before buying.

3 Best premium

Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood

Best for: Portable dual-zone outdoor cooking

Cooking Area

361 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane

Burners

2

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Integrated Hood

Material

Stainless Steel

View on Amazon: Blackstone Original 22" Tabletop Griddle with Hood Affiliate link

The Blackstone 1813 is a 22-inch tabletop griddle offering 361 square inches of cooking space. It features two independently heated zones for versatile cooking. The unit includes an integrated hood for protection and a rear grease management system. Weighing 37.5 pounds, it is designed for portability. This model suits those who want a complete outdoor cooking unit rather than just a replacement top.

Pros

• 361 square inches of cooking area
• Two independently heated zones
• Integrated protective hood
• Rear grease management system

Cons

• Heavier at 37.5 pounds than replacement tops
• Larger footprint than standard replacement griddles
• Higher cost than simple replacement surfaces

Good fit if

• You want a complete portable griddle unit
• You need two separate heat zones
• You prefer built-in grease management

Skip if

• You only need a replacement top plate
• You need a lightweight portable option
• You want the lowest price option

Verdict: Blackstone 1813 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle fits buyers seeking a complete, portable cooking station with dual zones and protection, rather than those replacing a broken top.

4 Best electric

Uniflasy 25x16 Cast Iron Griddle Insert

Best for: expanding cooking space on existing grills

Surface Material

Cast Iron

Cooking Dimensions

25 x 16 inches

Fuel Type

Electric, Gas, Charcoal

Placement

Outdoor

Application

Camping, Tailgating

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

View on Amazon: Uniflasy 25x16 Cast Iron Griddle Insert Affiliate link

This Uniflasy cast iron griddle measures 25 by 16 inches with a 3.2-inch height. It fits over gas, charcoal, or electric grills rather than standing alone. The heavy-duty iron construction resists warping and retains heat well. High side walls and grease grooves help manage cooking messes. You can use it for breakfast or dinner on various outdoor grill brands.

Pros

• 25 x 16 inch cooking surface
• Heavy-duty cast iron material
• Compatible with gas, charcoal, and electric grills
• High side walls prevent splashes
• Includes a handle for easy movement

Cons

• Requires an existing grill to function
• Must be hand-washed to protect coating
• Heavy and bulky for portable use

Good fit if

• You own a compatible gas or charcoal grill
• You want a large flat top cooking area
• You prefer durable cast iron construction

Skip if

• You need a standalone unit without a grill
• You want a lightweight portable option
• You prefer non-stick coated surfaces

Verdict: Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle 25x16 is a solid insert for owners of compatible outdoor grills who need extra cooking space. It suits those who prioritize heat retention and durability over portability.

5 Also great

Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hood

Best for: complete outdoor griddle setups with dual zones

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Built-in Hood

Placement

Outdoor

Application

Camping, Backyard

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

26 × 20 × 15 inches

View on Amazon: Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hood Affiliate link

This tabletop griddle features a 22-inch cooking surface with two independently controlled heat zones. It includes a built-in hood for wind protection and piezo ignition for quick startups. The unit measures 26 by 20 by 15 inches and weighs 49 pounds. You get a rear grease management system for easier cleanup. It suits those who want a complete outdoor cooking setup with integrated storage and heat retention.

Pros

• 22-inch griddle plate with even heat distribution
• Two independently controlled heat zones
• Built-in hood for wind protection
• Piezo ignition system for push-button starts
• Rear grease management system

Cons

• Heavier at 49 pounds than replacement tops
• Larger footprint requires more counter space
• Fixed tabletop design limits portability

Good fit if

• You need a complete griddle with a hood
• You want independent heat zone control
• You prefer piezo ignition over manual lighting

Skip if

• You only need a replacement top plate
• You require a lightweight portable unit
• You have limited storage space for a hood

Verdict: Blackstone 22-Inch OTG Griddle fits users who want a full outdoor cooking unit with a hood and dual zones rather than just a replacement part. It is a solid choice for permanent tabletop setups where weight and size are not primary constraints.

6 Also great

Blackstone 22-Inch OTG Dual-Zone Propane Griddle

Best for: Dual-zone tabletop propane cooking

Fuel Type

Propane

Form Factor

Tabletop

Placement

Outdoor

Application

Camping, Backyard

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

View on Amazon: Blackstone 22-Inch OTG Dual-Zone Propane Griddle Affiliate link

The Blackstone OTG is a 22-inch tabletop propane griddle featuring dual independent heat zones. This spec allows you to cook different foods at separate temperatures simultaneously. It includes a pre-seasoned Omnivore Blackout plate and rear grease channels for easy cleanup. The piezo ignition provides reliable lighting without batteries. It is a practical choice for outdoor cooking where portable power and flexible heat control matter.

Pros

• 22-inch cooking surface
• Dual independent heat zones
• Pre-seasoned Omnivore Blackout plate
• Piezo ignition (battery-free)
• Rear grease management channels

Cons

• Tabletop form factor requires a stable surface
• No built-in hood included in this model
• Propane fuel required for operation

Good fit if

• You need independent temperature control for different foods
• You want reliable ignition without carrying batteries
• You have a flat surface for a 22-inch tabletop unit

Skip if

• You prefer electric power sources
• You need a built-in hood for weather protection
• You require a permanent outdoor kitchen installation

Verdict: Blackstone OTG 22-Inch Propane Griddle fits buyers who value dual-zone flexibility and battery-free ignition for portable tabletop cooking.

7 Best portable

Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Gas Griddle

Best for: portable outdoor cooking with independent zones

Cooking Area

304 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Gas

Burners

3

Total Heat Output

25,500 BTU

Surface Material

Steel

Form Factor

Tabletop

View on Amazon: Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Gas Griddle Affiliate link

The Royal Gourmet PD1301S is a portable tabletop gas griddle with a 304-square-inch cooking surface. It delivers 25,500 BTU across three independent burners. The 3.5 mm steel top ensures even heat distribution. Its compact 24-inch size fits in car trunks. This unit suits outdoor adventures and backyard cooking. You get reliable piezo ignition and easy cleanup via a removable grease cup.

Pros

• 304 sq. in. steel cooking surface
• 25,500 BTU total heat output
• Three independent burners
• Piezo ignition system
• Portable tabletop form factor

Cons

• No built-in hood for heat retention
• Steel surface requires seasoning
• Single height option of 8.66 inches

Good fit if

• You need a portable griddle for camping
• You want three independent heat zones
• You prefer battery-free piezo ignition

Skip if

• You require a built-in hood
• You need stainless steel construction
• You want dual heat zones only

Verdict: Royal Gourmet 3-Burner Portable Griddle offers ample space and power for portable cooking. It fits buyers who prioritize mobility and independent burner control over enclosed heat retention.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions