BLACKSTONE or Pit Boss? Griddles Compared in 2026
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This comparison covers the BLACKSTONE vs pit boss griddle debate for outdoor cooking. Both units offer gas-powered flat-top surfaces for versatile meal preparation. The Blackstone 28-Inch model provides a larger 517-square-inch cooking area with a traditional steel plate. The Pit Boss 2-Burner offers a smaller 421-square-inch ceramic-coated surface. You must choose between maximum space and specialized non-stick technology based on your specific cooking needs.
Key differences
| Aspect | Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle | Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking Area | 517 sq. in. | 421 sq. in. |
| Surface Material | Omnivore Griddle Plate (Steel) | Non-stick armored ceramic |
| Heat Output | not listed | 26,000 BTU |
| Weight | 69 pounds | 110 pounds |
| Dimensions | 44 x 22.8 x 33 inches | 29 x 50 x 37 inches |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle if
- You need a larger 517-square-inch cooking surface for big batches.
- You prefer a lighter unit at 69 pounds for easier maneuverability.
- You want a traditional steel plate with built-in wind guards.
Choose Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle if
- You want a non-stick ceramic surface for easier food release.
- You need explicit heat output data at 26,000 BTU.
- You prefer folding side shelves with built-in tool hooks.
Verdict: The Blackstone suits those who prioritize raw cooking space and portability. The Pit Boss is better for cooks who value non-stick convenience and higher stated heat output. Choose based on whether you need more surface area or specialized coating.
Blackstone vs Pit Boss Griddle
Cooking Area
The Blackstone 1517 Original offers a generous 517 square inches of cooking space. This large surface allows you to prepare breakfast items like eggs and pancakes alongside dinner entrees such as steaks and potatoes simultaneously. In contrast, the Pit Boss 2-Burner provides 421 square inches. While still substantial, this is nearly 100 square inches less than the Blackstone. If you frequently host large gatherings or need to cook for a crowd, the Blackstone’s expanded footprint gives you more room to maneuver multiple dishes without crowding. The Pit Boss remains suitable for smaller groups or standard family meals.
Heat Output
The Pit Boss 2-Burner features two stainless steel gas burners delivering a total heat output of 26,000 BTU. This high BTU rating suggests rapid heating capabilities and strong thermal power for searing meats. The Blackstone 1517 Omnivore does not list a specific BTU figure in its published specifications. However, it highlights faster preheat and recovery times due to its Omnivore griddle plate design and built-in wind guards. Without a stated BTU number for the Blackstone, direct comparison of raw power is difficult. You must rely on the Pit Boss for explicit heat intensity data, while the Blackstone emphasizes efficiency and heat distribution instead.
Surface Material
Surface composition significantly affects maintenance and cooking experience. The Pit Boss utilizes a proprietary non-stick armored ceramic cooking surface. This ceramic coating is rust-resistant and designed to prevent food from sticking, which can simplify cleanup. The Blackstone 1517 uses a traditional steel plate. Steel griddles typically require seasoning to maintain a non-stick layer and protect against rust. The Blackstone description mentions durable construction but does not specify a non-stick coating. If you prefer a surface that resists sticking without extensive seasoning routines, the Pit Boss ceramic option offers a distinct advantage. Steel plates may require more initial preparation.
Portability
Mobility differs between these two units. The Blackstone 1517 weighs 69 pounds and includes two caster wheels for easy movement. It also features a side handle for maneuvering. The Pit Boss 2-Burner is heavier at 110 pounds. Despite the increased weight, it is described as a portable unit with a lift-off cooking top, which may aid in transport or storage. The Blackstone’s lower weight and integrated wheels make it easier to reposition on a patio or deck. The Pit Boss’s lift-off design offers a different kind of portability, potentially allowing for easier disassembly, but its overall mass requires more effort to move.
Included Accessories
Both units provide storage and prep solutions, but the Pit Boss includes unique organizational features. The Pit Boss comes with folding side shelves that have built-in tool hooks, a solid bottom shelf, a paper towel holder, and a trash bag holder. It also includes a hard cover. The Blackstone 1517 offers a side shelf, a side handle, and a rear grease management system. It also has a bottom shelf for storage. The Pit Boss provides more specialized holders for kitchen tools and waste management directly on the unit. The Blackstone focuses on essential prep space and grease management without the extra organizational hooks or included cover.
Which Griddle Fits Your Outdoor Cooking Needs
Large batch cooks needing max space
The Blackstone 1517 provides 517 square inches of cooking area. This generous surface allows you to prepare breakfast items like eggs and pancakes alongside dinner entrees such as steaks and potatoes simultaneously. The larger footprint supports bigger meals for families or groups who need ample room for multiple dishes at once.
Users wanting easy cleanup and non-stick surface
The Pit Boss 2-Burner features a proprietary non-stick armored ceramic cooking surface. This material simplifies food release and makes wiping down the griddle significantly easier compared to traditional steel plates. You benefit from reduced sticking and faster post-cook maintenance, which is ideal for those who prioritize convenience and quick cleanup after outdoor meals.
Cookers prioritizing high heat output
The Pit Boss unit delivers 26,000 BTU of total heat output from two stainless steel gas burners. This powerful energy input ensures rapid preheating and consistent high temperatures for searing meats. If you prefer intense heat for quick cooking cycles and robust performance, the higher BTU rating offers a distinct advantage over standard single-burner configurations.
Those needing heavy-duty stability
The Blackstone 1517 weighs 69 pounds and includes two caster wheels for maneuverability. This weight provides solid stability during use without being overly cumbersome to reposition. The durable construction and included side shelves offer practical storage and prep space, making it a reliable stationary option for users who value a sturdy, well-equipped cooking station.
The products compared
Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle
Best for: large outdoor cooking sessions
- Cooking Area
- 517 sq. in.
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Burners
- 2
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 22.8 × 44 × 33 inches
- Weight
- 69 pounds
View on Amazon: Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle Affiliate link
The Blackstone 1517 Omnivore Griddle offers 517 square inches of cooking space on a 28-inch surface. Its Omnivore griddle plate features built-in wind guards for faster preheat and better heat distribution. The unit weighs 69 pounds and measures 44 inches wide. It includes two side shelves for prep and a rear grease management system. Two caster wheels allow for easy maneuvering. This model suits you if you need a durable, efficient outdoor cooking surface.
Pros
- 517 square inches of cooking area
- Omnivore griddle plate with built-in wind guards
- Rear grease management system
- Two side shelves for prep space
Cons
- Heavier build at 69 pounds
- Requires assembly
- No side handle listed in specifications
Good fit if
- You want fast preheat times
- You need ample prep space
- You prefer rear grease management
Skip if
- You need a portable unit under 50 pounds
- You require side handles for moving
- You have limited storage space
Verdict: Blackstone 28 Inch Omnivore Griddle delivers efficient heat distribution and ample cooking space for serious outdoor cooks. It fits your needs if you prioritize cooking speed and cleanup convenience over lightweight portability.
Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle
Best for: high-heat portable grilling
- Cooking Area
- 421 square inches
- Fuel Type
- Propane Gas
- Burners
- 2
- Total Heat Output
- 26,000 BTU
- Surface Material
- Ceramic Coated
- Cooking Dimensions
- 23" L x 18" W
View on Amazon: Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle Affiliate link
The Pit Boss 2-Burner Griddle offers 421 square inches of ceramic-coated cooking space. It delivers 26,000 BTU from two stainless steel burners. The unit weighs 110 pounds and features a lift-off top. You get folding side shelves with tool hooks and a hard cover. This propane gas model suits those needing a portable station with ample heat.
Pros
- 421 square inches of ceramic-coated cooking area
- 26,000 BTU total heat output
- Lift-off cooking top for easy cleaning
- Folding side shelves with tool hooks
Cons
- Heavy at 110 pounds
- Large footprint at 50 inches long
- No digital temperature display
Good fit if
- You need a portable griddle with high heat
- You want a ceramic non-stick surface
- You have space for a 50-inch unit
Skip if
- You prefer a smaller 28-inch model
- You need a lightweight portable unit
- You want electric ignition
Verdict: Pit Boss 2-Burner Portable Griddle fits you if you want high BTU output and a lift-off top. It is a solid choice for those prioritizing cooking area and heat over compact size.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle | Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking Area | 517 sq. in. | 421 square inches |
| Fuel Type | Propane | Propane Gas |
| Burners | 2 | 2 |
| Total Heat Output | not stated | 26,000 BTU |
| Surface Material | not stated | Ceramic Coated |
| Cooking Dimensions | not stated | 23" L x 18" W |
| Cover Type | not stated | Hard Cover |
| Form Factor | not stated | Portable |
| Material | not stated | Ceramic |
| Included Accessories | not stated | Cover |
| Compatible Appliance | Griddle | Griddle |
| Cover | not stated | Hard Cover |
| Dimensions | 22.8 × 44 × 33 inches | 50 × 29 × 37 inches |
| Weight | 69 pounds | 110 pounds |
| Size | 28 Inch | 2 Burner |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Model | 1517 | 10807 |
Frequently asked questions
Which griddle is better for large family meals?
The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle is the better choice for large gatherings. It offers a 517-square-inch cooking surface, allowing you to prepare multiple dishes at once. Its 44-inch width provides ample space for family-sized portions. The Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle has a smaller footprint, making it less ideal for big batches.
Is the Pit Boss griddle portable?
Yes, the Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle is designed for portability. It features a portable form factor suitable for transport. However, it weighs 110 pounds, which is heavier than the Blackstone model. The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle weighs 69 pounds but is larger and less compact. Both units are gas-powered for outdoor use.
What material is the Pit Boss cooking surface made of?
The Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle uses a ceramic cooking surface. This material is noted for its durability and heat retention properties. The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle utilizes a traditional steel plate. Steel is known for quick heating and even distribution. Your choice depends on whether you prefer ceramic or steel for your cooking style.
Does the Pit Boss griddle come with a cover?
Yes, the Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle includes a hard cover. This accessory helps protect the unit from weather elements when not in use. The product data for the Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle does not list an included cover. You may need to purchase a separate protective cover for the Blackstone model if desired.
Which griddle is heavier and more stable?
The Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle is heavier, weighing 110 pounds. Its substantial weight can provide stability during high-heat cooking sessions. The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle weighs 69 pounds. While lighter, it still offers a robust build. Consider your need for stability versus ease of movement when deciding between these two units.
Can I cook breakfast and dinner at the same time on the Blackstone?
Yes, the Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle allows simultaneous cooking of different meals. Its large 517-square-inch surface lets you prepare eggs and pancakes alongside steaks and potatoes. The 44-inch width provides distinct zones for various food types. This versatility makes it efficient for large outdoor cooking sessions where you need to manage multiple dishes.
What is the fuel type for these griddles?
Both griddles use gas as their fuel source. The Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle specifically lists propane as compatible. The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle is also a gas-powered unit. This common fuel type allows you to use standard outdoor propane tanks. Ensure you have adequate fuel supply for your planned cooking duration.