MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan vs MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill: Spec Comparison
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are looking at the moasker 27 inch steel ash pan vs 17 inch cast iron grill. Both items are replacement parts for outdoor grills, designed to improve your cooking setup. The main difference lies in their function and material. One is a steel tray for charcoal management, while the other is a cast iron cooking surface for gas grills. Understanding these specs helps you pick the right part for your specific grill model and cooking style.
Key differences
| Aspect | MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan and Charcoal Tray | MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grates |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Porcelain-coated steel | Cast iron |
| Dimensions | 27" x 13" | 17" x 17.5" |
| Compatible Grill | Char-Griller, Charbroil, Kingsford | Charbroil Performance 2 Burner |
| Application | Ash collection and charcoal tray | Cooking grate |
| Included Accessories | 2 fire grate hangers | Not listed |
Which one should you choose?
Choose MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan and Charcoal Tray if
- You need a replacement ash pan for a charcoal grill.
- You want a durable steel tray with porcelain coating.
- You require included fire grate hangers for installation.
Choose MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grates if
- You are replacing cooking grates on a gas grill.
- You prefer cast iron for even heat distribution.
- You have a Charbroil Performance 2 Burner model.
Verdict: Choose the steel ash pan if you maintain a charcoal grill and need to manage ash and charcoal. Pick the cast iron grill grates if you own a Charbroil Performance 2 Burner gas grill and need a new cooking surface. The correct part depends entirely on your grill type and whether you need ash management or cooking space.
Specs: Steel Pan vs Cast Iron
Primary Material
The MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan is constructed from porcelain-coated steel. This finish provides a durable surface that resists rust and corrosion while offering a smooth interior for ash collection. In contrast, the MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grates are made from top-grade thicker cast iron. Cast iron is known for its heat retention and ability to sear food effectively. The steel pan focuses on containment and durability against ash, while the cast iron grate focuses on cooking performance and heat distribution for your food.
Compatibility
The steel ash pan is designed to fit Char-Griller charcoal models, including 1224, 1324, 2121, 2222, 2727, 2828, 2929, and E1224. It also fits Charbroil grills and replaces Kingsford charcoal barrel grill ashtrays. The cast iron grates are compatible with Charbroil Performance 2 Burner models, such as 463630021, 463655621, and 463644220. They also fit TRU-Infrared 2-Burner grills. Each part serves a specific brand ecosystem, so you must verify your grill model before purchasing either replacement component.
Dimensions
The ash pan measures 27 inches in length by 13 inches in width. This large footprint is necessary to cover the bottom of larger charcoal grills and hold a significant amount of ash and charcoal. The cast iron grates have a combined dimension of 17 inches by 17.5 inches for the 2-burner configuration. This includes one narrow grate at 17 by 7 inches and one larger grate at 17 by 10.5 inches. The pan is wider, while the grates are taller in total coverage.
Included Accessories
The steel ash pan package includes one ash pan and two fire grate hangers. These hangers help secure the fire grate in place above the ash collection area. The cast iron grates package includes the cooking grates themselves, specifically designed to replace the original grids. It does not list additional hardware like hangers or brackets in the standard package. If you need mounting hardware, the steel pan provides it, whereas the grates focus solely on the cooking surface.
Fuel Type
The steel ash pan is designed for charcoal grills. It sits at the bottom of the grill to collect ash and hold charcoal fuel. It is not a cooking surface. The cast iron grates are also used with charcoal or gas grills, depending on the model, but their primary function is to cook food. The steel pan manages the byproducts of burning charcoal, while the cast iron grate interacts directly with the heat to cook your meal. They serve opposite ends of the cooking process.
Which MOASKER Part Suits Your Grill
Charcoal grill owners needing ash management
You need to manage charcoal residue efficiently. This 27-inch steel ash pan measures 27 by 13 inches, providing a large capacity for holding charcoal and collecting ash. The porcelain-coated steel construction offers durability and a smooth surface that makes handling and disposing of ash easier. It fits Char-Griller models like the 1224 and 2727, ensuring a proper fit for your specific grill setup.
Gas grill owners replacing cooking grates
You require replacement cooking surfaces for your gas grill. This 17-inch cast iron grate set includes a narrow 17 by 7-inch piece and a larger 17 by 10.5-inch piece. The solid cast iron rods provide even heating and help release the original taste of your food. It is designed for Charbroil Performance 2-Burner models, offering a direct fit for your existing grill structure.
Users seeking durable, low-maintenance parts
You want a part that resists corrosion and simplifies cleanup. The porcelain-coated steel ash pan is designed to be durable and easy to install. Its large 27 by 13-inch surface area allows for efficient ash collection without frequent emptying. The smooth interior prevents ash from sticking, making post-grill cleanup quicker. This makes it a practical choice for maintaining a clean charcoal grill environment.
The products compared
MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan and Charcoal Tray
Best for: Char-Griller 1224 and 2727 owners
- Compatible Grill
- Char-Griller, Charbroil, Kingsford
- Material
- Porcelain-coated steel
- Dimensions
- 27" x 13"
- Finish
- Porcelain-coated
- Fuel Type
- Charcoal
View on Amazon: MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan and Charcoal Tray Affiliate link
This MOASKER ash pan is a replacement tray for charcoal grills. It measures 27 inches by 13 inches and is made from porcelain-coated steel. The package includes two fire grate hangers. It fits Char-Griller models like the 1224 and 2727, as well as select Charbroil and Kingsford units. You need to verify your original part before ordering. It offers large capacity for holding charcoal and ash.
Pros
- 27 x 13 inch dimensions for large capacity
- Porcelain-coated steel construction for durability
- Includes two fire grate hangers
- Compatible with multiple Char-Griller and Charbroil models
Cons
- Only fits specific charcoal grill models
- Requires manual verification of original part number
- Not suitable for gas or electric grills
Good fit if
- You own a Char-Griller 1224, 1324, 2121, 2222, or 2727
- You need a replacement for a Charbroil 17302056 or CB056-036
- You want a durable porcelain-coated steel ash tray
Skip if
- You have a gas or electric grill
- You need a pan larger than 27 inches
- You cannot verify your original part number
Verdict: MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan is a direct replacement for specific Char-Griller and Charbroil charcoal grills. It suits owners who need a large, durable tray and have verified their model compatibility.
MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grates
Best for: Charbroil Performance 2 Burner owners
- Compatible Grill
- Charbroil Performance 2 Burner
- Material
- Cast iron
- Dimensions
- 17" x 17.5"
- Grate Type
- Cooking grate
View on Amazon: MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grates Affiliate link
This is a replacement cooking grate for the Charbroil Performance 2 Burner grill. It is made from cast iron, which provides durable, even heating and natural non-stick properties. The set includes two pieces: a narrow 17 by 7 inch grate and a larger 17 by 10.5 inch grate. The total footprint is 17 by 17.5 inches. It fits specific Charbroil models like 463630021 and 463655621. You get solid rods for better heat distribution and easier cleaning.
Pros
- Made of thick cast iron for even heating
- Includes narrow and larger grate sections
- Natural non-stick surface without coating
- Easy to install and clean
Cons
- Only fits Charbroil Performance 2 Burner models
- Requires oiling to maintain non-stick surface
- Cast iron is heavier than steel alternatives
Good fit if
- You own a Charbroil Performance 2 Burner grill
- You want durable cast iron cooking surfaces
- You need replacement parts for models 463630021 or 463655621
Skip if
- You have a 4-burner or larger grill
- You prefer lightweight stainless steel grates
- You need a grate for a different brand
Verdict: MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grate is a solid replacement for Charbroil Performance 2 Burner owners who want durable, even heating. It fits specific models well but does not work for larger grills.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan and Charcoal Tray | MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grates |
|---|---|---|
| Compatible Grill | Char-Griller, Charbroil, Kingsford | Charbroil Performance 2 Burner |
| Material | Porcelain-coated steel | Cast iron |
| Dimensions | 27" x 13" | 17" x 17.5" |
| Grate Type | not stated | Cooking grate |
| Finish | Porcelain-coated | not stated |
| Fuel Type | Charcoal | not stated |
| Size | 27 " x 13 " | 17" x 17.5" for 2 Burner |
| Model | 03508 | not stated |
Frequently asked questions
Is the MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan a direct replacement for Char-Griller grills?
Yes, this steel ash pan is designed as a direct replacement for specific Char-Griller models, including the 1224 and 2727. It is also compatible with certain Charbroil charcoal grills. You should verify your grill model before purchasing to ensure the 27 by 13-inch tray fits correctly.
What size is the MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grate?
The cast iron grill grate measures 17 by 17.5 inches. It is specifically sized for the Charbroil Performance 2 Burner series. This dimension ensures it fits the cooking area of that specific two-burner model without requiring any modifications to your grill setup.
Can I use the 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grate on larger grills?
No, the 17-inch cast iron grate does not work for larger grills. It is engineered specifically for the Charbroil Performance 2 Burner. If you have a larger grill, this grate will likely not fit or provide adequate coverage for your cooking needs.
What material is the MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan made from?
The ash pan is constructed from porcelain-coated steel. This material choice provides a durable surface that resists rust and corrosion. The smooth interior finish aids in easy ash collection and cleaning, making it a practical choice for managing charcoal residue.
Who is the MOASKER 27-Inch Steel Ash Pan best for?
This ash pan is best for owners of Char-Griller 1224 and 2727 models who need efficient ash management. It is also suitable for owners of compatible Charbroil charcoal grills. If you need a large, durable tray to hold charcoal and collect ash, this part is a solid option.
Why choose the MOASKER 17-Inch Cast Iron Grill Grate?
You should choose this grate if you own a Charbroil Performance 2 Burner and want durable, even heating. Cast iron retains heat well and provides consistent cooking performance. It serves as a solid replacement for worn-out grates on your specific two-burner grill model.