Cast Iron vs Steel Grills: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are deciding between a cast iron vs steel grill for your outdoor cooking needs. Both units offer portable designs suitable for tailgating or camping, but they use different fuel sources and construction materials. The Oklahoma Joe's Rambler uses charcoal and features cast iron grates, while the Veralune unit runs on gas with stainless steel grates. Your choice depends on whether you prefer the heat retention of cast iron or the convenience of gas burners.
Key differences
| Aspect | Oklahoma Joe's Rambler Tabletop Charcoal Grill | Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill with Infrared Side Burner |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Charcoal | Gas |
| Grate Material | Cast Iron | Stainless Steel |
| Form Factor | Portable Tabletop | Portable Cart |
| Cooking Area | 218 sq. in. | not listed |
| Heat Control | Height-adjustable charcoal tray | 4 independent burners |
| Weight | 48.5 pounds | 94 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Oklahoma Joe's Rambler Tabletop Charcoal Grill if
- You want the intense sear marks and heat retention provided by cast iron grates.
- You prefer the authentic flavor of charcoal cooking over gas.
- You need a lighter, more compact unit that fits easily on a table.
Choose Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill with Infrared Side Burner if
- You want precise, independent temperature control for each burner.
- You prefer the quick startup and easy cleanup of a gas grill.
- You need a higher heat output for faster cooking sessions.
Verdict: Choose the Oklahoma Joe's Rambler if you prioritize the searing power of cast iron and a lighter, tabletop-friendly footprint. Pick the Veralune 4-Burner if you need the convenience of gas ignition and independent burner control. Both serve portable cooking well, but their fuel and material differences dictate their best use cases.
Cast Iron Grates vs Steel Build
Fuel Type
The Oklahoma Joe's Rambler relies on charcoal as its fuel source, which provides authentic smoky flavor and requires you to manage the fire manually. In contrast, the Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill uses gas, offering immediate ignition and consistent heat without the need for lighting charcoal or waiting for coals to ash over. You choose charcoal for traditional taste or gas for convenience and speed.
Cooking Area
Portability often means sacrificing space, but the difference here is stark. The Rambler offers 218 square inches of cooking area, which fits about six burgers or steaks. The Veralune provides a significantly larger surface due to its four main burners, allowing you to cook for a larger group simultaneously. If you are hosting a family dinner or tailgate with many guests, the Veralune’s expanded footprint handles more food in one go.
Material
Construction materials define durability and maintenance. The Rambler features heavy-duty steel construction with thick cast iron grates that retain heat well for strong sear marks. The Veralune is built primarily from stainless steel, which resists rust and corrosion more effectively than standard steel. Cast iron requires seasoning and care to prevent rust, while stainless steel offers a lower maintenance exterior that withstands the elements with less effort.
Heat Control
Temperature management differs significantly between these two designs. The Rambler uses a height-adjustable charcoal tray, allowing you to raise or lower the fire to control intensity for searing or slow cooking. The Veralune offers independent temperature control for each of its four burners, giving you precise zones for different types of food. You can adjust individual burners accurately, whereas the Rambler controls heat globally by moving the charcoal bed.
Dimensions
Size impacts where you can place these grills. The Rambler is compact at 26.8 inches wide and 19.5 inches long, making it easy to fit on small tables or in car trunks. The Veralune is much larger, measuring 49.6 inches wide and 18.1 inches long. While the Rambler is easier to transport and store, the Veralune requires a dedicated spot with ample space. You need more room for the gas model.
Features
Included features enhance usability for different scenarios. The Rambler includes a professional temperature gauge with glow-in-the-dark accents and a cool-touch rubber handle for safe lid operation. The Veralune adds a built-in thermometer and a push-pull oil pan for easy grease cleanup, plus an infrared side burner for extra cooking versatility. The gas model offers more specialized features for cleaning and side cooking, while the charcoal grill focuses on essential handling.
Weight
Portability is heavily influenced by weight. The Rambler weighs 48.5 pounds, making it manageable for one person to carry with its sturdy side handles. The Veralune weighs 94 pounds, which is nearly double the weight. This makes the gas grill much harder to move frequently, such as for camping trips. If you plan to carry your grill regularly, the lighter charcoal option is far more practical for your travels.
Which Grill Fits Your Cooking Style?
You want authentic charcoal flavor and portability
The Oklahoma Joe's Rambler uses charcoal for genuine smoky taste. Its heavy-duty steel body and cast iron grates retain heat for strong sears. The adjustable charcoal tray lets you control heat intensity easily. At 48.5 pounds, it is light enough for camping or tailgating while providing 218 square inches of cooking space for small gatherings.
You need high heat output and independent burners
The Veralune grill delivers 55,000 BTU across four main burners plus an infrared side burner. You get independent temperature control for each burner, allowing precise heat management. The built-in thermometer helps you monitor cooking accuracy in real time. This gas-powered unit offers powerful, consistent heating for larger or more complex cooking sessions.
You prefer easy cleanup and grease management
The Veralune features a push-pull oil pan design for quick grease removal. This system helps maintain hygiene and safety during and after cooking. The stainless steel construction resists corrosion and simplifies wiping down surfaces. You avoid the ash cleanup required by charcoal grills, making post-cooking maintenance faster and less messy for your outdoor kitchen routine.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Oklahoma Joe's Rambler Tabletop Charcoal Grill | portable charcoal grilling for small groups | Check price of Oklahoma Joe's Rambler Tabletop Charcoal Grill on Amazon |
| 2 | Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill with Infrared Side Burner | high-BTU backyard grilling | Check price of Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill with Infrared Side Burner on Amazon |
The products compared
Oklahoma Joe's Rambler Tabletop Charcoal Grill
Best for: portable charcoal grilling for small groups
- Material
- Cast Iron (what this guide is about)
- Fuel Type
- Charcoal
- Cooking Area
- 218 sq. in.
- Form Factor
- Portable Tabletop
- Primary Material
- Heavy-duty steel
- Features
- Cast Iron Grates
View on Amazon: Oklahoma Joe's Rambler Tabletop Charcoal Grill Affiliate link
The Oklahoma Joe's Rambler is a portable tabletop charcoal grill built with heavy-duty steel. It offers 218 square inches of cooking space, fitting up to six burgers or steaks. Thick cast-iron grates retain heat for strong sear marks. The height-adjustable charcoal tray lets you control heat intensity. A professional temperature gauge with glow-in-the-dark accents helps you track cooking heat. This compact unit suits smaller gatherings or outdoor travel.
Pros
- Heavy-duty steel construction provides durability.
- Thick cast-iron grates retain heat for even searing.
- Height-adjustable charcoal tray allows precise heat control.
- Professional temperature gauge with glow-in-the-dark accents.
Cons
- Limited 218 square inch cooking area restricts batch size.
- Charcoal fuel requires more preparation than gas.
- No side shelves or storage space included.
Good fit if
- You need a compact grill for tailgating or camping.
- You want authentic charcoal flavor in a portable unit.
- You cook for small groups of up to six people.
Skip if
- You prefer the convenience of gas fuel.
- You need to cook large batches for big parties.
- You want a permanent outdoor kitchen setup.
Verdict: Oklahoma Joe's Rambler 218 Sq. In. Charcoal Grill is a durable, portable option for campers or tailgaters who prioritize heat retention and authentic flavor over convenience.
Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill with Infrared Side Burner
Best for: high-BTU backyard grilling
- Material
- Steel (what this guide is about)
- Fuel Type
- Gas
- Heat Output
- 55,000 BTU
- Burner Count
- 4
- Primary Material
- Stainless steel
- Placement
- Outdoor
View on Amazon: Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill with Infrared Side Burner Affiliate link
This portable gas grill offers 55,000 BTU across four main burners and one infrared side burner. Its stainless steel construction supports outdoor use, while a built-in thermometer helps you monitor heat levels. You get independent control for each burner to adjust firepower precisely. The push-pull oil pan simplifies grease management. It fits well for backyard grilling or camping where stable heat and easy cleaning matter to you.
Pros
- 55,000 BTU heat output for strong performance
- Four stainless steel main burners plus one infrared side burner
- Independent temperature control for each burner
- Built-in thermometer for real-time monitoring
- Push-pull oil pan for easy grease cleaning
Cons
- Heavier at 94 pounds, making it less portable
- Larger footprint at 49.6 inches wide
- No mention of side shelves or storage space
Good fit if
- You want precise heat control for different cooking tasks
- You prefer stainless steel for durability and easy cleaning
- You need a high-BTU grill for steady cooking
Skip if
- You need a compact tabletop grill for easy transport
- You want a lightweight unit under 50 pounds
- You prefer cast iron grates for searing
Verdict: Veralune 4 Burner Steel Gas Grill suits those who prioritize high heat output and independent burner control. It is a solid choice for backyard cooking where stability matters more than portability.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Oklahoma Joe's Rambler Tabletop Charcoal Grill | Veralune 4-Burner Gas Grill with Infrared Side Burner |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Charcoal | Gas |
| Cooking Area | 218 sq. in. | not stated |
| Heat Output | not stated | 55,000 BTU |
| Burner Count | not stated | 4 |
| Form Factor | Portable Tabletop | not stated |
| Primary Material | Heavy-duty steel | Stainless steel |
| Placement | not stated | Outdoor |
| Application | not stated | Camping, Tailgating |
| Material | Cast Iron | Steel |
| Features | Cast Iron Grates | Side Burner, Thermometer |
| Heating Method | not stated | Infrared |
| Dimensions | 19.5 × 26.8 × 21.8 inches | 18.1 × 49.6 × 45.1 inches |
| Weight | 48.5 pounds | 94 pounds |
| Size | Portable | not stated |
| Color | Black | 4 Burner+1 Infrared |
| Model | 19402088 | XM-EQC64 |
Frequently asked questions
Does cast iron hold heat better than steel?
Yes, cast iron retains heat more effectively than thin steel. The Oklahoma Joe's Rambler uses cast iron grates to maintain consistent temperatures for searing. Steel grills like the Veralune model heat up faster but may lose warmth quicker once the flame is reduced.
Is a cast iron grill heavy and hard to move?
Cast iron grills are typically heavier due to the dense material. The Oklahoma Joe's Rambler weighs 48.5 pounds, making it portable but sturdy. Steel grills can also be heavy, like the 94-pound Veralune unit, but their frames are often designed for stationary backyard use.
Do I need to season a cast iron grill?
Yes, cast iron requires seasoning to prevent rust and create a non-stick surface. You must maintain the seasoning on the Rambler's grates regularly. Steel grills, such as those on the Veralune grill, often have porcelain coatings that resist rust without the same maintenance routine.
Which grill cooks faster, cast iron or steel?
Steel grills generally heat up faster because the metal is thinner. The Veralune gas grill provides immediate ignition and rapid heat output. Cast iron takes longer to warm up but holds that heat longer, which is ideal for slow cooking or keeping food warm.
Can I use a cast iron grill for tailgating?
Yes, provided you have help carrying it. The Oklahoma Joe's Rambler is designed for portability despite its weight. Its compact size fits in many vehicles. However, you must transport charcoal and lighter fluid separately, which adds to the logistical effort compared to gas grills.
Does steel rust if left outside?
Steel can rust if exposed to moisture without protection. The Veralune grill features a steel body that needs care to prevent corrosion. Cast iron also rusts easily if not seasoned or covered. Both materials benefit from protective covers when not in use to extend their lifespan.
Which grill offers better flavor, charcoal or gas?
Charcoal grills like the Rambler impart a smoky flavor that gas cannot replicate. The burning charcoal adds depth to meats and vegetables. Gas grills, such as the Veralune, offer cleaner heat without smoke, allowing you to taste the natural flavors of the food without additional smoky notes.
How do I clean the grates on these grills?
Cast iron grates require brushing while warm and occasional re-oiling. Steel grates on gas grills are often easier to wipe down. Avoid harsh abrasives on coated steel surfaces. Both types benefit from regular cleaning after each use to prevent buildup and maintain cooking performance.