i COVER vs M Comnova Outdoors Grill Covers: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing i COVER vs m comnova outdoors grill cover options, you face two distinct protection strategies. Both brands offer waterproof, UV-resistant covers for outdoor charcoal grills. The i COVER 29-inch round model targets vertical smokers and kettle grills with a drawstring closure. The M Comnova Outdoors 600D barrel cover is built for rectangular Char-Griller units without side fireboxes, using adjustable Velcro straps. Your choice depends on your grill shape and the security method you prefer for windy conditions.
Key differences
| Aspect | iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover | M Comnova 46-Inch 600D Barrel Grill Cover |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Oxford material with PVC coating | 600D Oxford fabric with PU coating |
| Dimensions | 29" x 29" x 38" | 46"L x 23"W x 48.5"H |
| Closure Type | Bottom drawstring | Adjustable Velcro straps |
| Compatible Appliance | 22" Weber grills, vertical smokers | Char-Griller barrel grills (no fire box) |
| UV Protection | UV-resistant | Withstands at least 3 years of UV aging |
Which one should you choose?
Choose iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover if
- You own a round kettle grill or vertical smoker that fits a 29-inch diameter.
- You prefer a bottom drawstring closure to secure the cover from below.
- You want a lightweight cover that is easy to rinse and maintain.
Choose M Comnova 46-Inch 600D Barrel Grill Cover if
- You have a rectangular Char-Griller barrel grill without a side firebox.
- You need adjustable Velcro straps to tighten the fit on varied widths.
- You want a heavier 600D fabric rated for three years of UV resistance.
Verdict: Choose the i COVER if you protect a round kettle grill or vertical smoker and prefer a drawstring seal. Select the M Comnova Outdoors cover for Char-Griller barrel grills, especially if you need the security of adjustable Velcro straps and heavier 600D fabric. Match the shape and closure style to your specific grill model for the best fit.
Cover Fit and Material Specs
Material durability
The M Comnova 46-Inch cover uses 600D Oxford fabric with a PU coating. The higher denier count suggests a thicker, more abrasion-resistant material compared to the standard Oxford material in the i COVER 29-inch model. M Comnova also highlights a UV test proving resistance to at least three years of aging. This specific durability metric is not listed for the i COVER brand, which only notes UV resistance and high-density stitching. For long-term outdoor exposure, the specified 600D rating and tested UV lifespan give M Comnova a clearer advantage in material robustness.
Waterproof technology
Both covers provide full waterproof protection for your outdoor grill. The i COVER 29-inch model relies on a PVC coating applied to its Oxford material to repel water and withstand torrential rain. The M Comnova 46-inch version uses a waterproof PU coating on its 600D fabric. While both methods effectively keep moisture out, the specific coating type differs. PVC is often stiffer, while PU can be more flexible. Since both achieve the same waterproof result according to their specs, you have a tie in terms of core weather protection capability.
Closure mechanism
Securing the cover against wind is handled differently by each brand. The i COVER 29-inch model features a bottom drawstring closure. This design pulls the fabric tight around the base of vertical smokers and kettle grills to prevent it from blowing off. The M Comnova 46-inch cover uses adjustable Velcro magic bands on the sides. This allows you to tighten the fit around irregular shapes like barrel grills. The drawstring offers a uniform seal, while Velcro provides adjustable tension, making this a tie based on your specific grill shape.
Fit compatibility
These covers are designed for distinct grill types. The i COVER 29-inch model is round, measuring 29 inches in diameter and 38 inches tall. It fits standard 22-inch Weber grills, vertical smokers, and barrel BBQs. The M Comnova 46-inch cover is rectangular, measuring 46 inches long, 23 inches wide, and 48.5 inches tall. It is specifically engineered for Char-Griller barrel grills without a side fire box. Because they target different grill geometries, neither is universally better. You must choose the shape that matches your equipment.
Stitching and edges
Both brands emphasize strong construction to prevent tearing. The i COVER 29-inch model features high-density double line stitching and double-layer bound edges. These bound edges are specifically designed to shield the grill from splashing water. The M Comnova 46-inch cover uses double-stitched seams on its 600D fabric. While both use double stitching, i COVER adds the detail of bound edges for extra water shielding. This specific edge treatment gives i COVER a slight advantage in preventing water ingress at the seams.
Choose the right grill cover for you
Char-Griller barrel grill owner without side box
The M Comnova cover measures 46 x 23 x 48.5 inches, fitting specific Char-Griller models like 2121 and 2828 without a side fire box. Its 600D Oxford fabric offers higher durability than standard options. Adjustable Velcro straps ensure a secure fit on these unique rectangular shapes, preventing wind damage while protecting against rain and UV exposure for at least three years.
Weber kettle or vertical smoker owner
The i COVER 29-inch round model is designed for 22-inch Weber grills and vertical smokers. It measures 29 x 29 x 38 inches with a dome shape that suits round appliances. The bottom drawstring closure provides a snug fit to keep out splashing water. Its PVC coating and double-layer bound edges offer reliable waterproof protection for standard kettle or bullet smokers.
Buyer prioritizing heavy-duty fabric density
The M Comnova cover uses 600D Oxford fabric, which indicates a thicker, more abrasion-resistant material compared to the standard Oxford material in the i COVER option. This higher denier count, combined with a waterproof PU coating and double-stitched seams, suggests superior resilience against wear and tear. It is built to withstand harsh weather conditions and prolonged sun exposure for years.
The products compared
iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover
Best for: standard 22-inch Weber kettle grills
- Compatible Appliance
- 22" Weber grills, vertical smokers
- Dimensions
- 29 x 29 x 38 inches
- Material
- Oxford material
- Waterproof Lining
- PVC coating
- Closure Type
- Bottom drawstring
- UV Protection
- UV-resistant
View on Amazon: iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover Affiliate link
This i COVER round grill cover measures 29 inches in diameter and 38 inches in height. It is built from Oxford material with a PVC coating to provide waterproof protection. The design includes UV-resistant fabric and double-layer bound edges to shield against weather. A bottom drawstring closure ensures a snug fit on vertical smokers and 22-inch Weber grills. It suits users needing durable, all-weather protection for standard kettle grills or barrel smokers.
Pros
- 29-inch diameter and 38-inch height fits standard vertical smokers
- Oxford material with PVC coating offers waterproof protection
- UV-resistant fabric shields against prolonged sunlight exposure
- Bottom drawstring closure prevents wind from lifting the cover
Cons
- Limited to round shape, not suitable for rectangular grills
- No side vents listed for airflow management
- Only available in Black and Charcoal colors
Good fit if
- You own a 22-inch Weber kettle grill
- You need a snug fit for a vertical barrel smoker
- You require waterproof protection for outdoor charcoal cooking
Skip if
- You have a rectangular or offset smoker
- You need a cover for a large offset grill
- You prefer a transparent material to see inside
Verdict: i COVER 29" Round Grill Cover is a practical shield for 22-inch Weber grills and vertical smokers. It fits users who prioritize waterproof Oxford material and a secure drawstring closure for standard round charcoal setups.
M Comnova 46-Inch 600D Barrel Grill Cover
Best for: Char-Griller barrel grills without side fireboxes
- Compatible Appliance
- Char-Griller barrel grills (no fire box)
- Dimensions
- 46"L x 23"W x 48.5"H
- Fabric Density
- 600D
- Material
- Oxford fabric
- Waterproof Lining
- PU coating
- Closure Type
- Adjustable velcro
View on Amazon: M Comnova 46-Inch 600D Barrel Grill Cover Affiliate link
This cover is built for Char-Griller barrel grills without a side firebox. It measures 46 inches long, 23 inches wide, and 48.5 inches high. The 600D Oxford fabric features a waterproof PU coating to repel rain and snow. Double-stitched seams add durability. Adjustable Velcro straps keep the cover secure in wind. It resists UV fading for at least three years. You get a tight fit and reliable protection for your outdoor charcoal grill.
Pros
- 600D Oxford fabric with waterproof PU coating
- Adjustable Velcro straps for secure wind resistance
- UV fading resistance for at least 3 years
- Double-stitched seams for heavy-duty durability
Cons
- Only fits Char-Griller barrel grills without a side firebox
- No included accessories beyond the cover itself
- Specific model compatibility limits broader use
Good fit if
- You own a Char-Griller barrel grill without a side firebox
- You need a cover with adjustable straps for windy conditions
- You want heavy-duty 600D fabric for long-term UV protection
Skip if
- You have a Char-Griller model with a side firebox
- You need a cover for a grill with different dimensions
- You require a universal fit for multiple grill types
Verdict: M Comnova 46x23x48.5" Barrel Grill Cover fits Char-Griller barrel grills without a side firebox perfectly. Its 600D fabric and adjustable straps provide secure, weather-resistant protection for your specific outdoor cooking setup.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover | M Comnova 46-Inch 600D Barrel Grill Cover |
|---|---|---|
| Compatible Appliance | 22" Weber grills, vertical smokers | Char-Griller barrel grills (no fire box) |
| Dimensions | 29 x 29 x 38 inches | 46"L x 23"W x 48.5"H |
| Fabric Density | not stated | 600D |
| Material | Oxford material | Oxford fabric |
| Waterproof Lining | PVC coating | PU coating |
| Closure Type | Bottom drawstring | Adjustable velcro |
| UV Protection | UV-resistant | At least 3 years UV aging |
| Fuel Type | Charcoal | Charcoal |
| Placement | Outdoor | Outdoor |
| Included Accessories | Cover | Cover |
| Style | Kettle | Barrel |
| Water Resistance | Waterproof | not stated |
| Size | 29" | not stated |
| Color | Black | 3) #5555 - 46 x 23 x 48.5 Inch (No Fire Box) |
| Model | G11601 | COGC-CG-5555-BLK |
Frequently asked questions
Which cover is better for a standard Weber kettle grill?
The i COVER 29-inch model is the better choice. It is designed specifically for 22-inch Weber kettles and vertical smokers. The dimensions are 29 by 29 by 38 inches. This size ensures a snug fit for standard round charcoal setups. You get a secure drawstring closure to keep the cover in place.
Does the M Comnova cover fit barrel grills with a side firebox?
No, it does not. The M Comnova 46-inch cover is explicitly made for Char-Griller barrel grills without a side firebox. It measures 46 by 23 by 48.5 inches. If your grill has an attached side firebox, this cover will not fit properly. You need a different size for that configuration.
What is the difference in fabric density between the two covers?
The M Comnova cover uses 600D Oxford fabric. The i COVER model uses standard Oxford material without a specified denier count. The 600D rating suggests the M Comnova fabric is thicker and more abrasion-resistant. This provides potentially better durability against rough handling or sharp edges on your grill.
Are both covers waterproof for outdoor use?
Yes, both brands offer waterproof protection. The i COVER is listed as waterproof with a PU coating. The M Comnova cover also features a PU coating on its 600D fabric. Both are designed for outdoor placement to shield your charcoal grill from rain and moisture.
How do the closure systems compare for securing the cover?
The i COVER uses a secure drawstring closure. This helps tighten the cover around the round shape of a kettle grill. The M Comnova cover relies on adjustable straps to fit the barrel shape. Both methods aim to keep the cover from blowing away in the wind.
What color options are available for these grill covers?
Both covers are available in black. The i COVER 29-inch model comes in black. The M Comnova 46-inch model is also black, specifically noted as color code #5555. This neutral color helps the covers blend in with most outdoor cooking setups without drawing attention.
Which cover is better for a vertical smoker?
The i COVER 29-inch model is better for vertical smokers. It is compatible with both kettle grills and vertical smokers. Its height of 38 inches accommodates the taller profile of many smokers. The M Comnova cover is sized for barrel grills and may not fit vertical units correctly.