Looking Beyond the Onlyfire 23" x 16" Universal? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You might be looking for onlyfire 23 x 16 universal alternatives to find a better fit for your outdoor cooking setup. The Onlyfire 23" x 16" Stainless Steel Griddle offers a robust stainless steel surface with even heat distribution and a detachable handle design. Its grease trough helps manage drippings for easier cleanup. However, you may need a different cooking area, a nonstick surface, or a specific brand compatibility that this model does not provide.
We selected 6 alternatives because their specifications overlap with the original product. These options include various sizes, from compact 17" plates to expansive 36" tops. Some feature nonstick coatings for simplified maintenance, while others are designed for specific grill brands like Napoleon or Camp Chef. Each choice prioritizes durable stainless steel construction. You can compare dimensions, weight, and material thickness to determine which griddle best suits your grill’s dimensions and your cooking habits. This guide focuses on how each spec applies to your actual use case.
Our top pick: Onlyfire 23x16 Stainless Steel Griddle.
How each alternative compares
Uniflasy 25" x 16" Stainless Steel Nonstick Griddle
The Uniflasy 25" x 16" Griddle offers a wider cooking surface at 25 inches compared to the Onlyfire’s 23 inches. It features a nonstick coating, which simplifies cleanup and reduces the need for oil. However, it weighs 19 pounds, significantly heavier than the Onlyfire’s 5 pounds, making it less portable. The extra width accommodates large batches, ideal for tailgating. If you prioritize easy release and maximum surface area over lightweight portability, this model suits your needs. The stainless steel construction remains durable, but the nonstick layer requires different care than bare metal.
Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
The Stanbroil 36-Inch Griddle Top provides a much larger cooking area, measuring 36 inches by 20.5 inches. It is designed specifically for Blackstone 36-inch grills, unlike the universal fit of the Onlyfire. At 3 inches tall, it sits higher than the Onlyfire’s 2.75-inch profile. This model is built for high-volume cooking and includes a dedicated rear grease drain. It is not a universal insert and will not fit other grill brands. Choose this if you own a compatible Blackstone unit and need extensive space for large gatherings. The stainless steel surface is robust, but the lack of universal compatibility limits its use.
Napoleon 20" x 16" Stainless Steel Griddle Insert
The Napoleon 20" x 16" Griddle Insert is engineered exclusively for Napoleon Freestyle and Rogue 425 grills. It does not fit universal setups or other brands. While the Onlyfire offers a 23-inch length, this insert is slightly shorter but tailored for precise fitment. It weighs 21.2 pounds, much heavier than the Onlyfire’s 5 pounds, ensuring stability on compatible grills. The stainless steel surface provides even heating. Select this option only if you own a matching Napoleon grill and want a seamless integration. It sacrifices universal flexibility for optimized performance on specific equipment.
Skyflame 17x13 Stainless Steel Griddle Plate
The Skyflame 17x13 Griddle Plate is a compact alternative to the larger Onlyfire model. It measures 17 inches by 12.8 inches, fitting smaller grills or tailgating setups where space is limited. At 6.44 pounds, it is slightly heavier than the Onlyfire but remains portable. The stainless steel surface is durable and includes grease management features. This option is ideal for cooks who need a smaller footprint or are transporting the griddle frequently. It lacks the expansive cooking area of the Onlyfire but offers a practical solution for compact outdoor kitchens or limited grill space.
Direct 18-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
The Direct 18-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top provides a middle-ground size at 18.1 inches by 12.5 inches. It is narrower and shorter than the Onlyfire’s 23-inch length. Weighing 9.75 pounds, it is heavier than the Onlyfire but lighter than larger commercial models. The stainless steel construction ensures durability and even heat distribution. This griddle suits gas grill owners who need a manageable size that fits standard setups without overwhelming the cooking area. It offers a balance between portability and cooking space, making it a solid choice for those who find the Onlyfire too large for their specific grill dimensions.
Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
The Stanbroil 28-Inch Griddle Top offers a substantial cooking surface at 28 inches by 17 inches. It is designed for Camp Chef grills, providing extra space for large batch cooking. Unlike the universal Onlyfire, this model is tailored for specific compatibility, ensuring a secure fit. It prioritizes capacity and wind protection over lightweight portability. The stainless steel surface is built for heavy use. Choose this if you own a compatible Camp Chef unit and need maximum cooking area. It sacrifices the universal flexibility of the Onlyfire for enhanced performance and stability on matching grill systems.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Onlyfire 23x16 Stainless Steel Griddle
Best for: Large gas grills needing durable stainless steel
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel
- Fuel Type
- Gas, Charcoal
- Application
- Camping, Tailgating
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 23 × 16 × 2.75 inches
- Weight
- 5 pounds
View on Amazon: Onlyfire 23x16 Stainless Steel Griddle Affiliate link
The Onlyfire 23" x 16" griddle offers a large cooking surface made from 100% food-grade stainless steel. Its 2.8-inch thickness and wavy hollow underside promote even heat distribution and airflow. Detachable handles allow for easy storage and transport. The raised sidewalls keep food on the surface, while the integrated grease trough manages drippings. This unit fits most gas grills with larger cooking areas.
Pros
- Large 23" x 16" cooking surface
- 100% food-grade stainless steel construction
- Wavy hollow underside for even heating
- Detachable handles for storage and transport
- Integrated grease trough for cleanup
Cons
- Heavier at 5 pounds than smaller inserts
- No nonstick coating for easy release
- Limited to standard gas grill compatibility
Good fit if
- You need a large surface for family meals
- You want durable stainless steel that resists deformation
- You prefer detachable handles for easier storage
Skip if
- You have a smaller grill with limited space
- You prefer a lightweight, easy-to-carry option
- You want a nonstick surface for delicate foods
Verdict: Onlyfire 23" x 16" Stainless Steel Griddle is a robust choice for those with larger gas grills who prioritize durability and even heat. It suits cooks who value stainless steel construction and organized cleanup over nonstick convenience.
Uniflasy 25" x 16" Stainless Steel Nonstick Griddle
Best for: large batch cooking on gas grills
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel, Nano Ceramic Coating
- Cooking Dimensions
- 25" x 16"
- Fuel Type
- Gas
- Placement
- Outdoor
- Application
- Camping, Tailgating
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
View on Amazon: Uniflasy 25" x 16" Stainless Steel Nonstick Griddle Affiliate link
The Uniflasy griddle measures 25 by 16 inches with a 2.89 inch height. It uses stainless steel with a nano-ceramic coating for even heat distribution. The design includes raised sidewalls and a grease trough to manage spills. At 19 pounds, it is lighter than cast iron options. This universal fit works on gas grills, charcoal grills, and stove tops for outdoor or indoor cooking.
Pros
- 25 by 16 inch cooking surface fits most gas grills
- Nano-ceramic nonstick coating resists scratches and warping
- Ventilation holes and support ridges ensure even heating
- Raised sidewalls and grease trough prevent flare-ups
- Detachable handles allow for easy storage and stacking
Cons
- Heavier at 19 pounds than thinner steel alternatives
- Nonstick coating requires careful cleaning to avoid damage
- No included stand or mounting hardware for grills
Good fit if
- You need a large surface for family-sized meals
- You want easy cleanup with nonstick properties
- You use a gas grill with compatible dimensions
Skip if
- You prefer traditional cast iron seasoning methods
- You have a grill with a smaller cooking area
- You need a griddle under 20 pounds for portability
Verdict: Uniflasy 25" x 16" Nonstick Griddle offers a spacious, nonstick surface ideal for those prioritizing easy cleanup and versatile cooking on gas grills or stovetops.
Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
Best for: Blackstone 36-inch owners upgrading to stainless steel
- Cooking Area
- 742 sq. in.
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 36 × 20.5 × 3 inches
View on Amazon: Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top Affiliate link
This replacement top gives you 742 square inches of stainless steel cooking area, measuring 36 by 20.5 by 3 inches. Built with a full-width rear grease trough and removable handles, it swaps directly onto selected 36-inch Blackstone bases. If you want maximum surface area on a compatible frame rather than a portable universal plate, this fits your setup.
Pros
- 742 square inches of cooking space
- Full-width rear grease trough with drain
- Corrosion-resistant stainless steel construction
- Removable handles for transport and placement
Cons
- Fits only specific 36-inch Blackstone models instead of universal grill grates
- Large 36 by 20.5-inch footprint requires dedicated full-size storage
Good fit if
- You own a compatible 36-inch Blackstone grill base.
- You need a large 742-square-inch stainless steel cooking surface.
Skip if
- You need a universal drop-in griddle that sits on standard grill grates.
- You have a Blackstone model number not on the compatible list.
Verdict: Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top suits Blackstone 36-inch owners seeking a heavy-duty stainless cooking surface with a dedicated rear grease drain.
Napoleon 20" x 16" Stainless Steel Griddle Insert
Best for: Napoleon Freestyle and Rogue 425 grill owners
- Fuel Type
- Grill Insert
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel
- Form Factor
- Griddle Insert
- Cooking Dimensions
- 20" x 16"
- Dimensions
- 18.2 × 3.2 × 22.7 inches
- Weight
- 21.2 pounds
View on Amazon: Napoleon 20" x 16" Stainless Steel Griddle Insert Affiliate link
The Napoleon griddle insert converts your gas grill into a flat-top cooking station. It features a 20 by 16 inch stainless steel surface for even heat distribution. The thick steel construction supports searing and sautéing. This accessory fits Freestyle and Rogue 425 models. It weighs 21.2 pounds and measures 18.2 by 3.2 by 22.7 inches. You get a dedicated griddle surface without buying a new appliance.
Pros
- Generous 20 by 16 inch cooking surface
- Thick stainless steel for even heat distribution
- Fits Freestyle and Rogue 425 gas grills
- Allows multi-zone cooking for searing and stir-frying
Cons
- Limited to specific Napoleon grill models
- Heavier at 21.2 pounds than universal inserts
- Smaller cooking area than 23 by 16 inch alternatives
Good fit if
- You own a Napoleon Freestyle or Rogue 425 grill
- You want a dedicated flat-top surface for your existing grill
- You prioritize even heat distribution from thick steel
Skip if
- You grill on a brand other than Napoleon
- You need a universal fit for multiple grill types
- You prefer a lighter, easier-to-handle insert
Verdict: Napoleon 20" x 16" Griddle Insert is the right choice if you own a compatible Napoleon grill and want a robust, even-heating surface for your existing unit. It does not fit other brands or universal setups.
Skyflame 17x13 Stainless Steel Griddle Plate
Best for: smaller grills and compact outdoor setups
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel
- Cooking Dimensions
- 17 x 13 in.
- Fuel Type
- Gas, Charcoal
- Application
- Camping, Tailgating
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 17 × 12.8 × 2.2 inches
View on Amazon: Skyflame 17x13 Stainless Steel Griddle Plate Affiliate link
The Skyflame griddle offers a 17 by 13 inch cooking surface made from restaurant-grade stainless steel. It features a built-in grease well to manage oil and reduce flare-ups. The underside cross-bracing promotes even heating across the plate. Side handles allow for easy movement, while the wavy side panels improve ventilation. This compact unit weighs 6.44 pounds and fits various outdoor cooking setups.
Pros
- 17 by 13 inch stainless steel cooking surface
- Built-in grease well for oil management
- Underside cross-bracing for even heating
- Wavy side panels for professional ventilation
- Side handles for easy movement
Cons
- Smaller 17 by 13 inch surface compared to 23 by 16 inch alternatives
- Heavier at 6.44 pounds than thinner options
- No nonstick coating on the stainless steel surface
Good fit if
- You need a smaller griddle for compact grills
- You prefer stainless steel durability over nonstick coatings
- You want built-in grease management to prevent flare-ups
Skip if
- You require a large 23 by 16 inch cooking area
- You prioritize lightweight portability under 5 pounds
- You want a nonstick surface for easier cleanup
Verdict: Skyflame 17x13 Stainless Steel Griddle suits those needing a durable, compact plate with grease management. It is a practical option for smaller grills or tailgating where space is limited.
Direct 18-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
Best for: gas grill owners needing a durable 18-inch surface
- Cooking Area
- almost 225 sq in
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel
- Cooking Dimensions
- 18" x 12.5"
- Fuel Type
- Gas
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
- Dimensions
- 18.1 × 12.5 × 2.75 inches
View on Amazon: Direct 18-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top Affiliate link
The Direct Store Parts DS126 is a stainless steel flat top griddle measuring 18.1 inches by 12.5 inches. It offers nearly 225 square inches of cooking surface and weighs 9.75 pounds. The unit includes handles on both sides for easier movement. It fits most gas grills and turns your outdoor cooking area into a versatile kitchen. This model is designed for durability and ease of cleaning.
Pros
- Stainless steel construction resists deformation
- Handles on both sides for easy carrying
- Flat smooth surface is easy to clean
- Nearly 225 square inches of cooking area
Cons
- Smaller cooking surface than the 23-inch models on this list
- Heavier build at 9.75 pounds may be cumbersome for some
- No nonstick coating mentioned, requiring proper seasoning
Good fit if
- You need a durable stainless steel griddle for a standard gas grill
- You prefer a surface that is easy to scrub clean
- You want handles on both sides for easier transport
Skip if
- You require a larger 23-inch cooking surface
- You are looking for a nonstick ceramic coating
- You need a lightweight griddle under 10 pounds
Verdict: Direct Store Parts DS126 18" Griddle is a solid choice for those who prioritize stainless steel durability and a manageable size for standard gas grills.
Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top
Best for: Camp Chef grill owners needing extra space
- Cooking Area
- 476 square in.
- Surface Material
- Stainless Steel
- Cooking Dimensions
- 28 x 17 inches
- Application
- Camping
- Compatible Appliance
- Griddle
View on Amazon: Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top Affiliate link
This Stanbroil griddle offers a 28 by 17 inch cooking surface with 476 square inches of space. It is made from durable stainless steel with high sides to block wind and dust. The design includes removable grease troughs and convenient side handles. It fits Camp Chef FTG600, FTG900PG, and FTG600P grills. You get a chemical-free flat top that resists drastic temperature changes.
Pros
- 28 by 17 inch stainless steel cooking surface
- 476 square inches of total cooking area
- Removable grease trough for easier cleaning
- High-side design inhibits grease splashing
Cons
- Specific compatibility limited to Camp Chef models
- No chemical-free coating listed for surface treatment
- Larger footprint than standard 23x16 inserts
Good fit if
- You own a Camp Chef FTG600 or FTG900PG grill
- You need extra cooking space for larger gatherings
- You prefer stainless steel over ceramic plates
Skip if
- You have a grill not listed in the compatible models
- You need a universal fit for multiple grill brands
- You prefer a smaller 23 by 16 inch footprint
Verdict: Stanbroil Stainless Steel Griddle 28x17 provides ample cooking area for Camp Chef owners. It suits those prioritizing capacity and wind protection over universal compatibility.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Onlyfire 23x16 Stainless Steel Griddle | Uniflasy 25" x 16" Stainless Steel Nonstick Griddle | Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top | Napoleon 20" x 16" Stainless Steel Griddle Insert | Skyflame 17x13 Stainless Steel Griddle Plate | Direct 18-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top | Stanbroil 28-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking Area | not stated | not stated | 742 sq. in. | not stated | not stated | almost 225 sq in | 476 square in. |
| Fuel Type | not stated | not stated | not stated | Grill Insert | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Surface Material | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel, Nano Ceramic Coating | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel |
| Form Factor | not stated | not stated | not stated | Griddle Insert | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Cooking Dimensions | not stated | 25" x 16" | not stated | 20" x 16" | 17 x 13 in. | 18" x 12.5" | 28 x 17 inches |
| Placement | not stated | Outdoor | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Application | Camping, Tailgating | Camping, Tailgating | not stated | not stated | Camping, Tailgating | not stated | Camping |
| Material | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel |
| Compatible Appliance | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle | Griddle |
| Dimensions | 23 × 16 × 2.75 inches | 25 × 16 × 2.89 inches | 36 × 20.5 × 3 inches | 18.2 × 3.2 × 22.7 inches | 17 × 12.8 × 2.2 inches | 18.1 × 12.5 × 2.75 inches | not stated |
| Weight | 5 pounds | 19 pounds | not stated | 21.2 pounds | 6.44 pounds | 9.75 pounds | not stated |
| Size | 23" x 16" x 2.8" | 25" x 16" x 2.9" | 36" x 20.5" x 3" | 18.2" x 3.2" x 22.7" | 17" x 12.8" x 2.2" | 18.1" x 12.5" x 2.8" | not stated |
| Color | Silver | Sliver | Silver | Stainless Steel | Silver | Stainless Steel | Silver |
| Model | F-BGG8206-SS | 60054 | L021-36-SS-V2 | 56093 | SK-QA0074-SS1 | DS126 | not stated |
Frequently asked questions
Are there smaller stainless steel griddles available?
Yes, the Skyflame 17x13 Stainless Steel Griddle Plate is a compact option. It measures 17 by 12.8 inches and weighs 6.44 pounds. This model suits smaller grills or tailgating where space is limited. The Direct 18-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top is another choice at 18.1 inches long. It weighs 9.75 pounds and fits standard gas grills.
Which alternative fits a Blackstone 36-inch grill?
The Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top is designed for Blackstone 36-inch owners. It measures 36 by 20.5 inches and includes a dedicated rear grease drain. This heavy-duty surface upgrades your existing unit. It is not a universal fit for other brands or setups. It provides a robust cooking area for large batches.
Is there a nonstick option for easier cleanup?
The Uniflasy 25" x 16" Stainless Steel Nonstick Griddle features a nonstick surface. It measures 25 by 16 inches and weighs 19 pounds. The coating simplifies cleanup and reduces the need for oil. It is suitable for gas grills or stovetops. This option prioritizes easy maintenance over the bare stainless steel finish of other models.
Does Napoleon make a compatible insert?
The Napoleon 20" x 16" Stainless Steel Griddle Insert is available. It is specifically for Napoleon Freestyle and Rogue 425 grill owners. The insert measures 18.2 by 22.7 inches and weighs 21.2 pounds. It does not fit other brands or universal setups. It provides a robust, even-heating surface for your existing compatible unit.
What is the largest cooking surface available?
The Stanbroil 36-Inch Stainless Steel Griddle Top offers the largest surface. It measures 36 by 20.5 inches. The Uniflasy 25" x 16" model is the next largest at 25 inches wide. The Onlyfire 23" x 16" model is also a spacious option. Larger surfaces accommodate more food but require more storage space and heavier grills.
Which griddle is best for Camp Chef owners?
The Stanbroil Stainless Steel Griddle 28x17 is ideal for Camp Chef owners. It provides ample cooking area for those needing extra space. It suits users who prioritize capacity and wind protection. This model is not a universal fit. It is designed specifically to enhance the cooking experience on Camp Chef grills.
How heavy are these stainless steel alternatives?
Weights vary by model. The Skyflame 17x13 weighs 6.44 pounds. The Onlyfire 23" x 16" weighs 5 pounds. The Direct 18-Inch model weighs 9.75 pounds. The Uniflasy 25" x 16" weighs 19 pounds. The Napoleon insert weighs 21.2 pounds. Heavier models offer more durability but are harder to move.