6 Best Alternatives to the Protebox 17" Silicone Griddle Mat (2026)

How these compare to Protebox

Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hard Cover

The Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle replaces a protective mat with a complete cooking appliance. You gain a dedicated propane-powered surface for dual-zone cooking rather than just covering an existing griddle. This option suits buyers who want portable, versatile heat for outdoor gatherings without relying on batteries. It includes a hard cover for protection when not in use. While the Protebox mat protects a 17-inch surface, this unit offers a 22-inch cooking area. You trade the simplicity of a silicone cover for the complexity and fuel needs of a gas griddle. It is a better choice if you need to cook rather than just protect.

Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle

The Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle provides solid heat output for its size, making it a practical choice for campers and tailgaters who need flexible cooking zones. Unlike the Protebox mat, which only covers a surface, this griddle delivers active cooking capability with gas and propane fuel. It features a tabletop form factor and includes a cover for storage. The dimensions are significantly larger than the 17-inch mat, offering more space for cooking. You give up the lightweight, foldable nature of the silicone mat for a heavier, 30-pound unit. This alternative is ideal if you prioritize cooking capacity and heat output over simple surface protection.

Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid with Thermometer

The Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid offers sturdy, weather-resistant protection with convenient hinged access for 22-inch Blackstone griddles. It adds utility with an integrated thermometer and windbreak capability, features absent in the Protebox silicone mat. This hard cover is designed for a larger griddle size, providing a more robust barrier against the elements. While the Protebox mat is flexible and folds for storage, this lid is rigid and fixed. You trade the portability and low profile of the silicone mat for enhanced durability and temperature monitoring. This option is best for owners of 22-inch griddles who want a permanent, protective solution that also aids in cooking management.

Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle

The Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle provides a robust ceramic cooking surface for those who want a dedicated portable griddle. It fits users who prioritize easy cleaning and high heat over the simplicity of a silicone mat. This unit uses gas and propane fuel and includes a hard cover. It is significantly larger and heavier than the Protebox mat, weighing 110 pounds compared to 13.4 ounces. You gain a specialized ceramic cooking surface and dual burners but lose the ability to simply drape a cover over an existing griddle. This alternative is suitable if you need a dedicated cooking appliance with high heat output rather than just protection for a flat top.

Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle

The Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle fits campers who want substantial cooking space and high heat output in a portable package. It serves as a robust alternative to simple mats for those prioritizing dedicated gas cooking. This unit features four burners and a foldable design for transport. It includes a hard cover for protection. The dimensions are much larger than the 17-inch mat, offering extensive cooking area. You trade the lightweight, inexpensive nature of the silicone mat for a complex, fuel-powered appliance. This option is ideal for tailgating or camping where you need active cooking power and large capacity rather than just surface protection for an existing griddle.

Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle

The Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle provides substantial cooking capacity and efficient heat for serious outdoor chefs. It suits those who prioritize cooking space and fuel efficiency over portability. This large griddle offers a 28-inch cooking surface, far exceeding the 17-inch coverage of the Protebox mat. It is designed for outdoor cooking with a robust build. Unlike the silicone mat, which is a passive protective layer, this is an active cooking device. You gain significant cooking area and professional-grade heat but lose the simplicity and low cost of a mat. This alternative is best for users who need a dedicated, large-scale griddle for serious outdoor cooking rather than just protecting a smaller surface.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Protebox 17" Silicone Griddle Mat

Best for: protecting 17-inch Blackstone griddles

Cooking Area

17" x 15.3"

Surface Material

Food Grade Silicone

Form Factor

Mat

Cooking Dimensions

17" L x 15.3" W

Included Accessories

Cover

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

View on Amazon: Protebox 17" Silicone Griddle Mat Affiliate link

This 17-inch silicone griddle mat is designed for Blackstone griddles. It measures 17 by 15.3 inches with a 0.5-inch height. The mat is made from heavy-duty food-grade silicone. It protects your griddle surface from rust, stains, and debris. The high-sided design helps collect moisture. You can fold it for storage. It is easy to clean due to its non-stick surface.

Pros

• Fits 17-inch Blackstone griddles perfectly
• Made of heavy-duty food-grade silicone
• Protects against rust and stains
• Easy to clean non-stick surface

Cons

• Only fits 17-inch griddle size
• Does not cover larger griddles
• Requires manual cleaning

Good fit if

• You own a 17-inch Blackstone griddle
• You want to prevent rust and stains
• You need a foldable storage solution

Skip if

• You have a griddle larger than 17 inches
• You prefer a rigid hard cover
• You need a mat for a different brand

Verdict: Protebox 17" Silicone Griddle Mat is a practical protective layer for owners of 17-inch Blackstone griddles who want to prevent rust and keep their cooking surface clean. It fits securely and folds away easily for storage.

2 Also great

Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hard Cover

Best for: portable dual-zone propane cooking

Fuel Type

Propane

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Hard Cover

Placement

Outdoor

Application

Camping, Backyard

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

View on Amazon: Blackstone 22-Inch Tabletop Griddle with Hard Cover Affiliate link

The Blackstone OTG is a 22-inch tabletop propane griddle designed for portable outdoor cooking. It features a pre-seasoned griddle plate and dual independent heat zones, allowing you to cook different foods at varying temperatures. The unit includes a hard cover for protection and uses piezo ignition for battery-free lighting. Its rear grease management system simplifies cleanup. This model suits those needing a durable, versatile cooking surface for gatherings.

Pros

• 22-inch pre-seasoned cooking surface
• Dual independent heat zones
• Piezo ignition for battery-free lighting
• Includes protective hard cover
• Rear grease management channels

Cons

• Tabletop form factor requires a stable surface
• Limited to propane fuel type
• No digital temperature controls

Good fit if

• You need independent heat zones for varied cooking
• You want a durable hard cover for storage
• You prefer battery-free ignition systems

Skip if

• You require electric power sources
• You need a built-in lid thermometer
• You want a permanent outdoor kitchen fixture

Verdict: Blackstone 22" OTG Propane Griddle delivers reliable dual-zone cooking with a protective hard cover. It fits buyers who need portable, versatile heat for outdoor gatherings without relying on batteries.

3 Also great

Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle

Best for: camping and tailgating

Cooking Area

316 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

3

Total Heat Output

25,500 BTU

Form Factor

Tabletop

Cover Type

Cover

View on Amazon: Royal Gourmet 24-Inch 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle Affiliate link

The Royal Gourmet PD1301R is a portable tabletop griddle fueled by propane. It offers 25,500 BTU of heat across a 316 square inch cooking surface. The unit weighs 30 pounds and includes a cover for protection. You get three separate burners for zone cooking. This setup suits small outdoor events like tailgating or camping where you need reliable, fast heating without a permanent station.

Pros

• 316 square inch cooking area
• 25,500 BTU total heat output
• Three separately controlled burners
• Includes protective cover

Cons

• 30 pounds is heavy for portability
• No digital temperature display
• Requires separate 20 lb propane tank

Good fit if

• You need zone cooking on a small surface
• You want a portable unit for tailgating
• You prefer gas heat over electric

Skip if

• You need a large permanent station
• You want a lightweight carry option
• You prefer electric power sources

Verdict: Royal Gourmet 3-Burner Tabletop Griddle delivers solid heat output for its size, making it a practical choice for campers and tailgaters who need flexible cooking zones.

4 Best budget

Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid with Thermometer

Best for: 22-inch Blackstone griddle owners

Form Factor

Tabletop

Features

Thermometer

Included Accessories

Cover

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Cover

Hard Cover

Dimensions

24 × 18 × 5 inches

View on Amazon: Unidanho 22-Inch Griddle Hinged Lid with Thermometer Affiliate link

This hard cover is designed for 22-inch Blackstone tabletop griddles like the Omnivore and Original models. It features a hinged lid with a cool-touch handle and a built-in thermometer for heat monitoring. The stainless steel construction offers all-weather protection against rust and dust. It also serves as a windbreak when open. This accessory suits owners of compatible griddles who want durable, convenient protection without removing the cover entirely.

Pros

• Hinged design with cool-touch handle for easy access
• Built-in round thermometer for precise heat monitoring
• Heavy-gauge stainless steel with powder-coated finish
• Doubles as a windbreak when open

Cons

• Specific to 22-inch griddles, not universal
• No app or remote connectivity
• Requires pre-drilled holes for mounting

Good fit if

• You own a 22-inch Blackstone griddle
• You want to monitor heat without lifting the lid
• You prefer a cover that stays attached

Skip if

• You have a griddle smaller than 22 inches
• You need a cover for a different brand
• You want a soft or vinyl cover

Verdict: Unidanho 22" Hinged Griddle Cover provides sturdy, weather-resistant protection with convenient hinged access. It fits 22-inch Blackstone griddles perfectly and adds utility with its integrated thermometer and windbreak capability.

5 Best ceramic

Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle

Best for: Ceramic surface portable griddling

Cooking Area

421 square inches

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

2

Total Heat Output

26,000 BTU

Surface Material

Ceramic Coated

Cooking Dimensions

23" L x 18" W

View on Amazon: Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle Affiliate link

This Pit Boss unit offers 421 square inches of cooking space with a ceramic-coated surface. It delivers 26,000 BTU from two stainless steel burners. The lift-off top weighs 55 pounds, making the entire 110-pound unit portable. You get folding side shelves, tool hooks, and a hard cover. This setup suits those who want a durable, non-stick ceramic cooking area without using silicone mats.

Pros

• 421 square inches of ceramic-coated cooking area
• 26,000 BTU total heat output from two burners
• Lift-off cooking top for easy cleaning
• Includes hard cover and folding side shelves

Cons

• Heavier at 110 pounds than silicone mats
• Requires propane gas and assembly
• Larger footprint than portable mats

Good fit if

• You want a non-stick ceramic surface
• You need high heat output for searing
• You prefer a dedicated portable griddle

Skip if

• You only want a silicone mat
• You have limited storage space
• You prefer electric cooking only

Verdict: Pit Boss 2-Burner Ceramic Griddle provides a robust ceramic cooking surface for those who want a dedicated portable griddle. It fits users who prioritize easy cleaning and high heat over the simplicity of a silicone mat.

6 Best premium

Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle

Best for: Camping and tailgating with high heat needs

Cooking Area

753 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane Gas

Burners

4

Total Heat Output

62,000 BTU

Cooking Dimensions

37" x 20"

Cover Type

Hard Cover

View on Amazon: Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle Affiliate link

The Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go is a portable propane griddle designed for camping and tailgating. It offers a 753 square inch cooking area with a 37-inch by 20-inch surface. The unit delivers 62,000 BTU across four separately controlled stainless steel burners. A 4.7mm thick griddle surface retains heat well. It includes a hard cover that doubles as a windscreen and features folding side shelves for tool storage.

Pros

• 753 square inch cooking area
• 62,000 BTU total heat output
• 4 separately controlled burners
• Includes hard cover windscreen
• Folding side shelves with hooks

Cons

• Requires propane fuel source
• Larger footprint than mat alternatives
• No electronic ignition system listed

Good fit if

• You need a dedicated portable griddle
• You cook for larger groups
• You prefer gas heat over electric

Skip if

• You only want a silicone mat
• You need a compact tabletop unit
• You prefer electric power sources

Verdict: The Pit Boss 4-Burner Fold & Go Griddle fits campers who want substantial cooking space and high heat output in a portable package. It serves as a robust alternative to simple mats for those prioritizing dedicated gas cooking.

7 Also great

Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle

Best for: large outdoor cooking capacity

Cooking Area

517 sq. in.

Fuel Type

Propane

Burners

2

Compatible Appliance

Griddle

Dimensions

22.8 × 44 × 33 inches

Weight

69 pounds

View on Amazon: Blackstone 28-Inch Omnivore Griddle Affiliate link

The Blackstone 1517 offers 517 square inches of cooking space on a 28-inch surface. It features a dedicated Omnivore griddle plate designed for faster preheat times, better heat distribution, and reduced fuel consumption. The unit includes side shelves and a rear grease management system for organized prep and cleanup. Weighing 69 pounds, it moves easily on caster wheels, making it a sturdy option for outdoor cooking.

Pros

• 517 square inches of cooking area
• Omnivore griddle plate for efficient heat
• Built-in wind guards and side shelves
• Rear grease management system
• Caster wheels for easy movement

Cons

• 69-pound weight requires effort to move
• No integrated lid or hood included
• 1-year limited warranty coverage

Good fit if

• You need a large surface for family meals
• You want efficient heat distribution and fuel use
• You prefer easy cleanup with rear grease management

Skip if

• You require a portable, lightweight unit
• You need a built-in protective cover
• You have limited outdoor storage space

Verdict: Blackstone 28" Omnivore Griddle provides substantial cooking capacity and efficient heat for serious outdoor chefs. It suits those who prioritize cooking space and fuel efficiency over portability.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• apexstone silicone coffee tamper mat alternatives
• dopict massage mat alternatives