Charbroil vs i COVER Grill Covers: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you search for charbroil vs i COVER grill cover options, you need to match the cover to your appliance shape. Both brands protect outdoor gear from weather. Char-Broil makes a large rectangular cover for wide gas grills. i COVER offers a round cover for vertical smokers and kettle grills. The main difference is form factor. One fits long, wide units. The other fits round, tall units. Choosing the right shape ensures proper coverage.
Key differences
| Aspect | Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover | iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover |
|---|---|---|
| Form Factor | Rectangular (72" W x 24" D x 42" H) | Round (29" Dia x 38" H) |
| Material | 18mil polyester fabric with sun fade liner | Oxford material with PVC coating |
| Water Resistance | Sealed seams for water resistance | Waterproof with PVC coating |
| Closure | Not listed | Bottom drawstring closure |
| Compatible Appliance | 5+ burner gas grills, up to 72" wide | 22" Weber grills, vertical smokers |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover if
- You have a wide gas grill or smoker up to 72 inches long.
- You prefer a cover made from heavy-duty polyester fabric.
Choose iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover if
- You own a round kettle grill or vertical bullet smoker.
- You want a waterproof cover with a drawstring to secure it in wind.
Verdict: Choose the Char-Broil cover if you need protection for a large, rectangular gas grill. Pick the i COVER option if you have a round kettle grill or vertical smoker. Each brand specializes in a different shape to keep your specific appliance safe.
Comparing Cover Materials and Shapes
Form factor
Char-Broil offers a rectangular design tailored for wide, linear appliances. The Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover measures 72 inches wide by 42 inches high and 24 inches deep. It fits 5, 6, or 7 burner gas grills, x-large combos, and charcoal smokers. i COVER provides a round dome shape. Its 29-Inch Round Grill Cover has a 29-inch diameter and 38-inch height. This shape suits vertical smokers, barrel BBQs, and 22-inch Weber kettle grills. You must match the cover geometry to your appliance. A rectangular cover will not fit a round smoker securely. A round cover will leave corners of a wide grill exposed.
Material
The Char-Broil Performance cover uses 18mil polyester fabric. It includes a sun fade protective liner to help resist UV damage. The material is described as heavy duty premium. i COVER uses oxford material with a PVC coating. This combination makes the cover waterproof and weather-resistant. The oxford fabric is noted as lightweight yet sturdy. Polyester typically offers good breathability, while PVC-coated oxford provides a stronger barrier against liquid water. You should choose the material that matches your local climate. If you face heavy rain, the PVC coating on the i COVER may offer superior liquid protection. If you face intense sun, the specialized liner on the Char-Broil may help preserve color longer.
Water resistance
Both covers address water protection, but through different mechanisms. The Char-Broil cover features sealed seams for water resistance. This design choice helps prevent moisture from seeping through the stitch lines. It also provides UV protection for fade resistance. i COVER takes a more aggressive approach with a PVC coating on its oxford material. It is explicitly labeled as waterproof. The i COVER also has a double-layer bound edge to shield against splashing water and torrential rain. If your area experiences frequent heavy downpours, the i COVER’s waterproof rating and bound edges may provide better peace of mind. The Char-Broil sealed seams are effective for general weather but may not handle standing water as well.
Closure and fit
Fit security differs significantly between the two brands. The i COVER round grill cover includes a bottom drawstring closure. This feature allows you to tighten the cover around the base of your smoker or grill. It ensures a snug fit that helps prevent the cover from blowing off in the wind. The Char-Broil Performance cover does not list a drawstring or strap system in its specifications. It relies on its large dimensions to drape over the appliance. For a 72-inch grill, the sheer size may provide enough tension, but you lack the ability to cinch it down. If you live in a windy area, the i COVER’s drawstring offers a clear advantage for stability.
Durability features
Both brands emphasize durability through stitching and material strength. The i COVER uses high-density double line stitching and high-density hemming. This construction is designed to withstand wear and tear from harsh weather. The Char-Broil cover highlights its 18mil fabric thickness and sealed seams. Thicker fabric generally resists tearing better. i COVER also mentions rip-resistant properties due to the double stitching. Char-Broil focuses on the premium nature of its polyester. If you prioritize resistance to physical abrasion and wind flapping, the i COVER’s reinforced stitching is notable. If you prioritize fabric thickness and UV-specific protection, the Char-Broil 18mil liner is the stronger choice.
Weight
The Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover weighs 2.68 pounds. This weight suggests a substantial, heavy-duty material that will not blow away easily on its own. The i COVER does not list a specific weight in its specifications. However, it is described as lightweight. This makes it easier to handle and store when not in use. A lighter cover is convenient for frequent adjustments. A heavier cover like the Char-Broil may stay in place better without additional straps, but it is harder to lift and secure. You should consider how often you need to remove the cover for maintenance. The Char-Broil’s weight adds stability, while the i COVER’s lightness adds convenience.
Which grill cover fits your appliance?
Owner of a wide 5+ burner gas grill
You need a cover that matches the rectangular footprint of large gas grills. This Char-Broil model measures 72 inches wide by 42 inches high and 24 inches deep. It is designed specifically for 5, 6, or 7 burner setups. The 18mil polyester fabric provides a heavy-duty barrier. Sealed seams offer water resistance, while the sun fade protective liner shields the material from UV damage.
Owner of a 22-inch kettle grill or smoker
You require a round cover for a 22-inch Weber grill or vertical smoker. This iCOVER option fits a 29-inch diameter and 38-inch height. It features a bottom drawstring closure for a snug fit that resists wind. The Oxford material includes a PVC coating for waterproof protection. High-density double line stitching ensures durability against wear and tear from harsh weather conditions.
User seeking easy maintenance and wind resistance
You value a cover that stays in place and cleans easily. The iCOVER design includes a bottom drawstring to prevent blowing off. Its waterproof PVC coating allows you to hose it down quickly to remove dirt. The UV-resistant material withstands prolonged sunlight exposure. This round cover is lightweight yet sturdy, making it ideal for protecting charcoal kettles and barrel smokers from splashing water.
The products compared
Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover
Best for: Large 5+ burner gas grills
- Compatible Appliance
- 5-7 burner gas grills up to 72" wide
- Dimensions
- 72 x 24 x 42 inches
- Fabric Density
- 18 mil
- Material
- Polyester
- UV Protection
- UV protection
- Included Accessories
- Cover
View on Amazon: Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover Affiliate link
This Char-Broil cover fits grills up to 72 inches wide. It uses 18mil polyester fabric with sealed seams for water resistance. A sun fade protective liner helps prevent UV damage. The tan cover measures 72 inches wide, 24 inches deep, and 42 inches high. It weighs 2.68 pounds. You should choose this if you have a large gas or charcoal grill that needs reliable weather protection.
Pros
- Fits grills up to 72 inches wide
- 18mil polyester fabric for durability
- Sealed seams for water resistance
- Sun fade protective liner included
Cons
- Limited to 42 inches in height
- Only available in tan color
- No locking straps or handles listed
Good fit if
- You need coverage for a 5+ burner grill
- You want sealed seams for water resistance
- You prefer a lightweight 2.68-pound cover
Skip if
- You have a grill wider than 72 inches
- You need a cover taller than 42 inches
- You require a specific color other than tan
Verdict: Char-Broil 72-Inch Extra Large Grill Cover provides solid protection for large grills with its 18mil fabric and sealed seams. It is a practical option for owners of 5+ burner gas grills who need standard weather resistance.
iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover
Best for: Standard 22-inch kettle grills and vertical smokers
- Compatible Appliance
- 22" Weber grills, vertical smokers
- Dimensions
- 29 x 29 x 38 inches
- Material
- Oxford material
- Waterproof Lining
- PVC coating
- Closure Type
- Bottom drawstring
- UV Protection
- UV-resistant
View on Amazon: iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover Affiliate link
This i COVER dome protects 22-inch kettle grills and vertical smokers. The 29-inch diameter and 38-inch height fit most standard round smokers. Oxford fabric with PVC coating blocks rain and UV rays. Double-layer edges and bottom drawstrings keep wind out. You get all-weather durability for outdoor charcoal or pellet smokers without needing complex assembly.
Pros
- 29-inch diameter fits standard 22-inch grills
- 38-inch height accommodates vertical smokers
- Waterproof PVC coating resists rain
- UV-resistant material protects against sun damage
- Bottom drawstring ensures a snug fit
Cons
- Only fits round or dome-shaped units
- No included accessories beyond the cover
- Limited to black and charcoal colors
Good fit if
- You own a 22-inch Weber kettle grill
- You use a vertical drum smoker
- You need UV protection for outdoor gear
Skip if
- You have a large offset smoker
- You need a cover for rectangular grills
- You require a tight fit for small electric grills
Verdict: i COVER 29" Dome Grill Cover suits owners of standard round smokers and kettle grills who need reliable waterproof protection. It is a practical shield for vertical smokers but does not fit larger or rectangular cooking units.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover | iCOVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover |
|---|---|---|
| Compatible Appliance | 5-7 burner gas grills up to 72" wide | 22" Weber grills, vertical smokers |
| Dimensions | 72 x 24 x 42 inches | 29 x 29 x 38 inches |
| Fabric Density | 18 mil | not stated |
| Material | Polyester | Oxford material |
| Waterproof Lining | not stated | PVC coating |
| Closure Type | not stated | Bottom drawstring |
| UV Protection | UV protection | UV-resistant |
| Fuel Type | Gas | Charcoal |
| Placement | not stated | Outdoor |
| Included Accessories | Cover | Cover |
| Style | not stated | Kettle |
| Water Resistance | not stated | Waterproof |
| Weight | 2.68 pounds | not stated |
| Size | 5+ Burner: Extra Large | 29" |
| Color | Tan | Black |
| Model | 2655579P04 | G11601 |
Frequently asked questions
Does Char-Broil make a cover for round grills?
The provided Char-Broil option is rectangular, not round. The Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover measures 72 inches wide by 42 inches high. It is designed for large gas grills with five or more burners. If you have a kettle grill, this rectangular cover will not fit properly. You should look for a round-specific model instead.
Is the i COVER grill cover waterproof?
Yes, the i COVER 29-Inch Round Grill and Smoker Cover is listed as waterproof. This feature protects your appliance from rain and moisture. It is suitable for outdoor placement near charcoal or vertical smokers. The black fabric helps shield your equipment from the elements while maintaining a standard kettle grill footprint.
What size grill does the i COVER fit?
The i COVER model is sized at 29 inches. It fits standard 22-inch kettle grills and vertical smokers. The cover dimensions are 29 inches wide, 29 inches deep, and 38 inches high. This shape accommodates dome-style appliances. It is not suitable for larger rectangular grills or wider cooking units.
How heavy is the Char-Broil grill cover?
The Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover weighs 2.68 pounds. This weight suggests a durable 18mil fabric construction. The sealed seams add to its protective quality for large grills. It is a practical option for owners of wide gas grills who need standard weather resistance without excessive bulk.
Can I use the i COVER on a gas grill?
The i COVER is specified for charcoal appliances like kettle grills and smokers. Its round shape matches standard 22-inch units. It is not designed for the rectangular footprint of most gas grills. If you own a gas grill with multiple burners, the Char-Broil rectangular cover is the more appropriate choice for your appliance.
What color is the Char-Broil grill cover?
The Char-Broil Performance 72-Inch Grill Cover is tan. This color is visible on the 72-inch extra-large model. It is designed for large grills with five or more burners. The tan fabric provides solid protection with its 18mil material and sealed seams. It offers a standard weather-resistant option for outdoor cooking equipment.